AJ Green versus Allen Robinson

[slaughterrt]

16 team 2QB tiered ppr league. TE premium. Full IDP. All that good stuff...

I am a strong competitor this year and have been talking to another owner who is in full rebuild.

I have offered him my Allen Robinson (IR obviously) for his AJ Green.

How does this look? I get an upgrade at WR who will play this year and help my lineup. I lose a little bit with Father Time, but am ok with that. Rebuild team gains youth at WR and lessens his starting lineup —> meaning better chance at 1.01 rookie pick. I’m sure he doesn’t want to accidentally win games at this point.

Fair offer or am I low?

[Goddard]

Seems like an even deal on both ends, but I like it especially for your team since you're competing.

[lukkynumber13]

AJG and ARob are a perfect marriage for scenarios like this. I just made a similar move for team 2 (gave up Robinson+ for AJG+)

Super fair and mutually beneficial

[slaughterrt]

AJG and ARob are a perfect marriage for scenarios like this. I just made a similar move for team 2 (gave up Robinson+ for AJG+)

Super fair and mutually beneficial

I’m hoping the other owner agrees.

[Kramer]

I'd rather have AJ Green in both scenarios. Too many question marks with ARob right now. I would be willing to do ARob and a late 1st for Green though (assuming you're a contender).

[tom14cat14]

I'd rather have AJ Green in both scenarios. Too many question marks with ARob right now. I would be willing to do ARob and a late 1st for Green though (assuming you're a contender).

I agree with this 2. I would consider selling green for Arob and a mid 2nd or better.

[erkk]

I would rather have AJ Green in this case. Even if you weren’t contending. As stated above, I’d add a pick to get the deal done. Arob has a high upside and that’s the story but we haven’t seen his full potential and we may not given Bortles there. I just traded Arob and 2 firsts for Julio and have no regrets.

[slaughterrt]

Trade accepted.

[Vcize]

I would rather have AJ Green in this case. Even if you weren’t contending. As stated above, I’d add a pick to get the deal done. Arob has a high upside and that’s the story but we haven’t seen his full potential and we may not given Bortles there. I just traded Arob and 2 firsts for Julio and have no regrets.

That seems like a major overpay.

AJG >> Julio and most seem to have ARob at least near AJG.

[wildabeast49]

I would rather have AJ Green in this case. Even if you weren’t contending. As stated above, I’d add a pick to get the deal done. Arob has a high upside and that’s the story but we haven’t seen his full potential and we may not given Bortles there. I just traded Arob and 2 firsts for Julio and have no regrets.

We havent seen Arob's full potential? So you're saying he's going to go for more than 1400 and 14 sometime... Arob and 2 firsts feels like a big overpay to me as well. I like the op deal as it seems to give both sides what they need.

[erkk]

I would rather have AJ Green in this case. Even if you weren’t contending. As stated above, I’d add a pick to get the deal done. Arob has a high upside and that’s the story but we haven’t seen his full potential and we may not given Bortles there. I just traded Arob and 2 firsts for Julio and have no regrets.

We havent seen Arob's full potential? So you're saying he's going to go for more than 1400 and 14 sometime... Arob and 2 firsts feels like a big overpay to me as well. I like the op deal as it seems to give both sides what they need.

Yea, I stand corrected. We certainly have seen his potential. But as an Arob owner I just have been frustrated the last 2 season to the point I may not value him as high now. Especially with his injuries and Bortles’ digression. My point was really that Arob for AJG is a great deal and would add to get the job done since the guy is competing. I also agree that ARob and 2 firsts is a bit of an overpay for Julio (could have used these comments in my Arob for Julio Thread) but I also am in a league where owners overvalue everyone. I’m competing, Arob went down, then OBJ went down, I don’t value picks that much, and so I was willing to add an extra pick to get the deal done. I would disagree that AJG is far greater than Julio. But hey I own both and next year I’ll have OBJ, AJG, and Julio. I can live with that.

[pierson242]

Id prefer AJG in both scenarios. Would need at least a 2nd added to Arob