Eli vs Tannehill

[Detroitcity]

Had Tannehill and Palmer both go down in a Superflex league (also have Dak), so I've been looking to pickup another QB. An owner that has Eli and Flaaco offered either one of those guys up for Tannehill + 2nd

I've been debating on who I would actually prefer between Eli and Flaaco, and then also whether I like either one of them more long term than Tannehill. Obviously Tannehill is younger, but he was kind of on the hot seat heading into the year and who knows what happens with him going forward. While Flaaco and Eli aren't world beaters, at least I can count on them not losing their jobs.

Thoughts on Flaaco vs Eli? And would you trade a Tannehill/ 2nd for either ?

[skip]

I like Tannehill more than either one.

[Magic derivative]

I wouldn't touch Eli he may have hit his age wall, flacco if you are making a playoff run, otherwise just hold on tannehill.

[vixen]

i think that is not a bad price to pay for a QB in a superflex league...if you are in the running for money, i would make the trade...if not, i would probably just muddle through for the rest of the season...flacco would probably be my choice and i would probably trade tannehill

[Goddard]

I probably prefer Flacco over Eli, only because he's younger and will probably have a job longer. If you're trying to compete this year, I wouldn't mind moving Tanny for him, but wouldn't add a 2nd...maybe a 3rd if you have to.

[dipANDglide]

Give me Tanny