Foreman or Henry? Trade advice *poll*

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

with Foreman blocked by Miller the next couple of years, I'd rather have Henry who is more likely to supplant Murray sooner than later.

Is he though? We've been saying Henry will supplant Murray for a year and a half now, but Murray is still the clear starter when even somewhat healthy...Both Murray and Miller have little to no guaranteed money on their contracts after this season. Honestly I think Foreman isn't as physically gifted as Henry but has talent of a similar level. I think Henry >= Foreman for the most part. They are both dart throws in good situations behind a starter, so give me the side that's getting the 1st.

[onetwothree]

I know some people seem to like what they've seen in Foreman. When he's gotten enough volume he tends to break a big run but otherwise he's not nearly as impressive as Henry. The modified offer I'd consider fair, but with Foreman blocked by Miller the next couple of years, I'd rather have Henry who is more likely to supplant Murray sooner than later.

Aren't you using the same argument to dock one player and prop up the other? Neither team seems likely to push the incumbent out any time soon.

[lukkynumber13]

with Foreman blocked by Miller the next couple of years, I'd rather have Henry who is more likely to supplant Murray sooner than later.

Is he though? We've been saying Henry will supplant Murray for a year and a half now, but Murray is still the clear starter when even somewhat healthy...Both Murray and Miller have little to no guaranteed money on their contracts after this season. Honestly I think Foreman isn't as physically gifted as Henry but has talent of a similar level. I think Henry >= Foreman for the most part. They are both dart throws in good situations behind a starter, so give me the side that's getting the 1st.

X2

These are both Ben Tate situations. I don't hate either player, and I don't hate them as assets. But Henry & Foreman are close enough to where that pick makes up my mind for me.