Hopkins or Mixon/Adams

[Needalife]

For team in sig, would you trade Mixon and Davante Adams for Hopkins? I'm currently middle of the pack in 12-team

QB - Brees
RB - Le'Veon, Fournette
WR - Evans, Adams
TE - Delanie
3 FX - Mixon, Rudolph, Doyle (TE premium)

Next tier... Gio, Aaron Jones, Gallman, Ginn, Marvin Jones, M Wallace

I would replace Adams with Hopkins and then have to replace Mixon with one of the guys in the "next tier" as I list above.

[Slackalacker]

I feel like that's a bit heavy for Nuk, but I would still take him. I'd see if the other side would throw in a 2nd

[Thedudewhogetshigh]

I would. I don't believe in Adam's long term this seems like a good price for him

[smoger45]

the way Watson is moving the ball its a easy yes from me.

[mlynarcm]

Ditto. Hopkins for me

[Goddard]

Hopkins, but very close for me.

[BradysBunch]

I am pretty high on Mixon, but I would take Hopkins with your team.

[RB6]

Hopkins. I'd try and get even a 3rd added. But if that's a deal breaker, just Hopkins.

[IR1]

Hopkins, but very close for me.

x2

[BigBawseRoss]

any other top wr not named Adams and i would have voted for mixon/?

[moishetreats]

I'll go against the grain here.

1) I am a believer in Hopkins. I don't think that Watson will sustain his TD rate, though, and he has only had one game of more than 76 yards this year.

2) Adams's 2017 value takes a hit without Rodgers.

3) Mixon is off to a slow start.

Nonetheless, I'd keep your duo. First of all, you don't have the depth to replace them for bye weeks or injuries. In addition, long-term, I think that Adams will be closer to Hopkins than most believe. And I also think that Mixon will be a difference-maker at RB.

In order for you to "win" this trade, you need all three of the above things to remain in your favor: Hopkins sustaining his TD rate this year; Adams dropping a lot without Rodgers; and Mixon having a poor year. If any of those three turns, then I think that you'll be regretting this trade in 2017 and certainly in the future.

I'd hold.