OBJ for Evans...

[asuchy333]

I'm sitting at 4-2, and this OBJ injury is hurting me...

Owner of Evans is 1-5.

Should he add on the Evans side, and if so, thoughts on how much?

[Slackalacker]

No he shouldn't add, OBJ side should add because Evans will play the rest of the season and OBJ will not.

OBJ side should add I'd say a 2nd. Since he's Out of contention there's a chance they'd do straight up depending on their favoritism between the two but arguably OBJ and Evans are basically equal.

[EAGLES]

Agree, Evans side shouldn’t add. You should be adding since Evans will be playing the remainder of this year.

[nathanq42]

Whoever initiated the trade of equal assets should add a little bit. Especially since obj is out and Evans isnt you should add a bit more.

[dblj1199]

Jumping on the bandwagon here, OBJ sides needs to add something. You need the player, he will want something more in return. Only way you may be able to pull if off as a 1 for 1 deal is to sell him on the fact that without a elite wr he will continue to lose and help him lock up the top draft pick.

[jcc6fd]

I definitely still prefer OBJ as a dynasty asset and would rather have him on my roster this offseason, but like others have said they were near equals before the season started and now only Evans will give you any fantasy production for the rest of the year. Adding a 2nd for that production seems appropriate to me.

[The Red Rooster]

If you are going to him I would almost guarantee he responds saying he values Evans over OBJ (even when both are healthy)...he should atleast. I think you should expect to have to add more. He would have to LOVE OBJ compared to Evans to make this trade. An even swap just doesnt make a lot of sense for him otherwise.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

I'd explore OBJ + Mike Williams for Evans and an older RB if he has any given you have David Johnson and Ezekiel Elliott out right now. You could use a Frank Gore or Legarrette Blount type to get you through the next few weeks at RB2.

[hockeyBjj]

OBJ sides adds most definitely. If both were healthy, then I'm not sure either side needs to add

[cweds]

Doesn't hurt to lead with a straight across trade. Their value isn't different enough at this point that it will offend him. Worst case scenario he asks you to add, best case he accepts it knowing he's getting the better player long term and knowing he's out of contention this year anyways.

I would also bring up the fact that swapping Evans for OBJ could help him earn a higher pick in the draft. Last thing he needs is some blowup games from Evans winning him some matches. Not tanking in my eyes, just playing smart.

[believeinthehunter]

that is option 1A and 1B, Evans is attached to the hip to a young QB, and he is a bigger more physically imposing receiver, personaly speaking I would take Evans over OBJ in a startup draft anyways, so you already know which way im leaning.

[Goddard]

This should be an even swap. Evans is worth more to a competing team and OBJ is worth more to a team in rebuild. Makes sense for both teams.

[asuchy333]

Thanks for all the replies, guys.

I offered OBJ + 19.3 for Evans. We'll see what he says. He seems to be holding tight for now though.

[Jaguars8907]

I agree with pretty much everything said above