Was offered OBJ for Mixon, K Allen, 1st, +

[hockeyBjj]

This board is huge on Mixon so I want to check here first before jumping at it. He initially wanted Dalvin Cook but I cried about being a Vikings fan so he countered with this. Team 1 in sig

I give Keenan Allen, Mixon, Gio, 1st that looks to be 8-9 in a 10 teamer (I have my own 1st still which will be 3-5 after this trade I think)
I get OBJ, J Thomas, either Periman or Yeldon, and a 2nd

Jump right? Having OBJ and Mike Evans on the same team would be awesome.Or hold because Mixon potential. I think this is as good as the deal will get from his side. He's a multi defending league champ. I initially started with asking about Keenan Allen and Jarvis Landry + as a base and he responded wanting Cook in there and now we're to this.

Previous offer was Cook, K Allen and that 1st for OBJ and an early 3rd. I think this is even a better offer than that regardless of the Cook/Mixon flip

[ace1250]

I like the OBJ side only because of OBJ. Mixon will be good, but OBJ is a freak... 10 team league you need STARS.. mixon COULD get there.. OBJ IS there.. OBJ and Evans is a nice 1-2 and next year you have them and Cook... 3 STARS to build on... Get the known player, let others gamble on the future.

[Slackalacker]

Mixon + Allen + 1st is buying a little higher on OBJ than I'd like, if you could do a second and remove his second I'd much rather do that.

But if not I'd probably still do it. Your WRs will be stacked for years to come and you can get a solid RB with your soon to be early 1st to go with Ajayi and Cook.

[Triton85]

^this, I'd tried to pull the 1st and just give up your 2nd. Can take 2 RBs in the 1st next year and hope they hit

[hockeyBjj]

Mixon + Allen + 1st is buying a little higher on OBJ than I'd like, if you could do a second and remove his second I'd much rather do that.

I don't have a second for next year (bundled with Trubisky to get another first) but even if I did I don't think he'll go for it. I can maybe ask about it being a 2019 1st and him dropping the 2nd and the other roster filling players but again I'm doubting it

Thank you for the feedback all who have voted/commented so far. At least I know I'm not an idiot for not instant accepting and saying I'd think about it

[hockeyBjj]

He didn't have a 2018 first so he really wanted that. Got him to add an early 3rd and I threw back a fourth. Tiny stuff, but I now have a pick in every round again which is nice for if people fall oddly. I have Evans and OBJ to look forward to next year, plus Cook coming back and hopefully an improved O-Line for Russel Wilson and Ajayi remembering how to play football. 2-4 start to the year with being 7th out of 10 on total points so here's my punt I guess

Now to see how bad I can finish this season without setting off our team's strict anti-tanking rules to get a high draft capital RB to replace Mixon with.

[Goddard]

Very close. If the 1st was early, I'd take the Mixon side...but OBJ for now.

[dhanks91]

I'd make the move, rolling out obj Evans and Landry every week is killer. I think you have the players on your roster to potentially fill the depth gaps you'd be losing

[hockeyBjj]

Very close. If the 1st was early, I'd take the Mixon side...but OBJ for now.

That first looking late was the reason I was still going for the trade. Its owner is 4-2 (only 1 guy in league 5-1) and the points scored leader by a good amount. Kareem Hunt, Jordan Howard, A Brown, Diggs, and Cam Newton playing again this week have given him the high score 2 or 3 times this year already. He also has Jacksonville and Baltimore defense which with our stupid D scoring is putting up 20-30+ points with a favorable matchup. I have my own first which now looks early . I'd love for it to be top 2 but not sure I can get it that low

It's close, but I wasn't going to be able to fleece this owner anyway. I like my side but it seems very fair

I'd make the move, rolling out obj Evans and Landry every week is killer. I think you have the players on your roster to potentially fill the depth gaps you'd be losing

WR I'm perfectly fine on. Have Thielen and Corey Davis behind Landry still. My RBs I'm in trouble though. Dalvin Cook, but Jay Ajayi is making me angry and then after that my best is now either James White, Riddick, or Frank Gore. I really tried hard to get him to go for Keenan Allen and Jarvis Landry + first or something but he was determined for a running back and I chose to give up Mixon rather than Cook due in large part to being a Vikings fan. We'll see if that backfires on me or not

I'll be trying to mull over how to get something at my RB position

[jcc6fd]

Think opinions vary widely on Mixon, but even if you love him OBJ side still has more value.

[Suhmdog]

I'd do it. Your team would be set years at wr. Top 2 dynasty wr on same team

[Pats/VikesFan]

OBJ side, easily.