T Hill or C Davis?

[BuckeyeNation]

Hill in his 2nd year is just getting going and he is a top 5 WR tbh I can see him being a better Hilton , So give me the guy that is already producing in the NFL over the guy sitting in the trainers room

Top 5 WR? Return yardage league?

I own several shares of Hill and none of Davis, but I'd still want Davis.

[AresGodOWar]

Hill in his 2nd year is just getting going and he is a top 5 WR tbh I can see him being a better Hilton , So give me the guy that is already producing in the NFL over the guy sitting in the trainers room

Top 5 WR? Return yardage league?

I own several shares of Hill and none of Davis, but I'd still want Davis.

no return yards , right now he is #3 in 1 ppr and .5 ppr , #2 in non ppr TD for kick returns leagues but that's counting that he played already this week , He is like #10 in ppg in the ppr leagues though but never know some of the guys ahead of him can have a bad week and he should move up in ppg ranks

[BuckeyeNation]

Hill in his 2nd year is just getting going and he is a top 5 WR tbh I can see him being a better Hilton , So give me the guy that is already producing in the NFL over the guy sitting in the trainers room

Top 5 WR? Return yardage league?

I own several shares of Hill and none of Davis, but I'd still want Davis.

no return yards , right now he is #3 in 1 ppr and .5 ppr , #2 in non ppr TD for kick returns leagues but that's counting that he played already this week , He is like #10 in ppg in the ppr leagues though but never know some of the guys ahead of him can have a bad week and he should move up in ppg ranks

Oh okay, that's where you got "top 5". It's a little misleading to say a guy is a "top 5 WR" when only one game has been played this week, and several teams have already had their bye. So he's played one more game than every other relevant WR except Cooper/Crabtree , and 2 more games than all the WRs that have already had their bye.

[AresGodOWar]

Top 5 WR? Return yardage league?

I own several shares of Hill and none of Davis, but I'd still want Davis.

no return yards , right now he is #3 in 1 ppr and .5 ppr , #2 in non ppr TD for kick returns leagues but that's counting that he played already this week , He is like #10 in ppg in the ppr leagues though but never know some of the guys ahead of him can have a bad week and he should move up in ppg ranks

Oh okay, that's where you got "top 5". It's a little misleading to say a guy is a "top 5 WR" when only one game has been played this week, and several teams have already had their bye. So he's played one more game than every other relevant WR except Cooper/Crabtree , and 2 more games than all the WRs that have already had their bye.

I mean he is still top 10 in PPG and only 2.8 ppg out of the top 3 , 2 out of top 5 , Fuller is top 5 in ppg he will fall out of there

[MontrealBen]

Bringing this back up because I'm facing this question. I'm in the middle of the pack right now, with some serious depth question marks.

QB - Goff
RB - Fournette, CJA, Collins, Lewis
WR - Evans, Jeffery, Sammy, Ginn, Davis, Doctson
TE - Gronk, Graham (yes, I'm trying to move Graham)

We start 2 RB, 2 WR, 1 RB/WR flex each week (10 teams, keep 5 players/year so it's not full on dynasty). Each week I feel like I'm scrambling to find a viable flex (& RB2, but that's beside the point for now). The Tyreek owner is out of the playoffs and is knocking on my door about Davis. He first asked about his Funchess for my Davis, which I shot down. Now I'm debating whether or not Tyreek is really the guy to put me over the top this year and if that's a counter I should make. My gut reaction is to stay with Davis, but I'm not sure if that's just me being biased toward the guy already on my roster.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Can you sell Sammy + Graham for Hill + 3rd or something along those lines?

[MontrealBen]

He'll have no interest in Graham. He has Engram and is a big Giants homer. A nice idea though...

Here's his roster (leavng out the QBs, which he is hoarding for some reason)

RB - DJ, Darwka, Powell
WR - OBJ, Hill, Funchess, Juju, Sanu
TE - Engram

[The Red Rooster]

At this point, I would probably deal Davis or Watkins for Hill straight up. The fact that he opened with Funchess for Davis though makes me think you wont be prying Hill away from him.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

He'll have no interest in Graham. He has Engram and is a big Giants homer. A nice idea though...

Here's his roster (leavng out the QBs, which he is hoarding for some reason)

RB - DJ, Darwka, Powell
WR - OBJ, Hill, Funchess, Juju, Sanu
TE - Engram

Davis for Hill + Powell?