C. Coleman for Garcon

[joeya2001]

im thinking of offering the owner, fair swap?

[Jaguars8907]

Yeah that's pretty fair. If I had to boil it down to anything:

Coleman > future
Garcon > now

[Goddard]

Agree with above. If you're competing, I'd take Garcon, if not go with Coleman.

[Slackalacker]

Coleman in a rebuild garçon for win now. Their acceptance depends on what position they are in

[The Red Rooster]

I would rather have Coleman whether I was in win now or a rebuild.

[skip]

I'd rather just have Coleman as he's the better talent.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

I'd try and get a 3rd back as well. I'm not a big Coleman fan, but worth a shot based on current market value.

[flyersfan1981]

I'd rather just have Coleman as he's the better talent.

Is he though? Garcon was a very good player for a lot of years. Coleman has not shown anything yet, and it is going to be another year where he shows nothing. I tried to tell anyone who would listen to sell Coleman when they had the chance, few listened. I ma not paying more than a 2018 2nd for Coleman, and if I was trying to win and needed WR help, I would easily ship that same pick for Garcon.

[skip]

I'd rather just have Coleman as he's the better talent.

Is he though? Garcon was a very good player for a lot of years. Coleman has not shown anything yet, and it is going to be another year where he shows nothing. I tried to tell anyone who would listen to sell Coleman when they had the chance, few listened. I ma not paying more than a 2018 2nd for Coleman, and if I was trying to win and needed WR help, I would easily ship that same pick for Garcon.

Garcon was in a great offense in Indianapolis but drops issues were always a problem as were his poor routes. Manning didn't trust him and he never produced more than above average numbers at best. It wasn't until 2013 he finally produced once in Washington. He then regressed again and it wasn't until last year with Cousins for a full season did he reach 1,000 yards for the 2nd time in his career. Frankly, I was surprised at those season totals, though when you only score 3 TDs and reach 100 yards in a game just once it's no surprise that no one noticed. He's now 31 years old and at the back end of his career. Definitely not someone I'd be buying and I'm certainly not going to trade off a better skill set player in Coleman. I'm not moving his level of talent simply because he's been struck hard by injuries since he came into the league and not had the opportunity to flash on the field. Garcon has had years to show what he can do and there's just not much to be impressed with.