superflex trade

[vixen]

i have an owner coming hard at me for Carr

i really like Carr and believe it or not, with the insane scoring in this league, i think i have a good chance at the playoffs

---superflex/TE premium 1-2QB 1-6RB 2-7WR 1-6TE (10 total)
R/W=.2ppc/1ppr/.25pt per target TE=1.5ppr/.35per target/.15per yd
also .1pt per return yd/.05 per attempt
Wilson, Carr, Stafford, Kaepernick, Kelly
Cook, Abdullah/Zenner, Dion/White, Ivory, Sproles, McGuire
Watkins, Lockett, Jo Brown, Patterson, Funchess, DGB/Agholor, K Wright, Kupp, Ch Williams, Darboh, Kearse, D Thompson, A Wilson
Gronk, Reed, Ertz, Swoope

his latest offer is:
i get Luck and Hilton
i give Carr
that seems like a great offer, but what do we know about Luck's injury? is this a career problem, or just this season? this owner also needs RBs..
he has expressed no interest in Wilson, but i could try to do something like wilson and sproles (could even throw in a 3rd round pick) for Luck

what are your thoughts on the trade offered (luck/hilton for carr) or should i counter with wilson/sprole/3rd for Luck?
thanks for you opinions

[Dynasty DeLorean]

Jeez that seems like a really good offer. You'd still have 2 QB's and you could buy a cheap 3rd one.

edit: Your RB's and WR's are in pretty bad shape, I think you should take this

[EAGLES]

I have a bad feeling about Luck. The Colts have done nothing to help ensure his longevity in the league. He’s had multiple injuries due to all the hits he takes. When I think of Luck, RG3 comes to mind (yes, Luck is extremely more talented). RG3 was ran into the ground and injury after injury riddled him. IMO, Luck is on the same path of an injury career.

With that said, I’m keeping Carr (I’m high on him too) and I’d make the counter with Wilson to see what he says.

[slaughterrt]

Would definitely keep Carr and Stafford unless you get a ridiculous overpay. Both of them are in their prime and have great passing offenses around them. Move Wilson because he is definitely a step down from the other two.

[vixen]

Jeez that seems like a really good offer. You'd still have 2 QB's and you could buy a cheap 3rd one.

edit: Your RB's and WR's are in pretty bad shape, I think you should take this

yes, they appear terrible, but this is crazy scoring and i can start all 3 of my TEs...so this team is much better than it looks on paper..

cook and james white are currently ranked RB15 and RB16
return yds increase the value of lockett and patterson
lockett, agholor, kearse, kupp, patterson and thompson are all top 30 for WRs (also watkins now, but he has played one more game than the rest of the WRs)

[Kramer]

Luck > Carr
Hilton > Nothing

[vixen]

Luck > Carr
Hilton > Nothing

it sure seems like it, but at this point i think that is not the case...i am still considering, but both are unstartable right now

[vixen]

so, how about Luck for Wilson and james white?

[Seventy5]

Hilton is free here, and its not like he's some minor secondary piece being thrown in. Luck>Carr the minute reports of Luck being cleared to even practice, so if you can sort out a cheap QB2 to start until luck comes back, this is a no brainer.

Yea it will suck not having carr for a few weeks until Luck comes back, but remember the big picture here. Anybody preferring Carr over Luck right now is stuck in redraft mode, and I am a Raiders fan saying that

[vixen]

so do you like
i give wilson and white (or abdullah)
i get luck

OR
i give Carr
i get Luck and Hilton

[vixen]

...

[smbkrypt24]

I like the original offer as well as the offer you later stated. Take the deals.

[vixen]

so, my thought process
1. will Luck (or Indy) be able to figure this out, without getting injured each season
2. will Wilson (and Seattle) turn this around, or is it time to sell him while i can
3. can Carr keep this up, or am i overvaluing him

do i give up a little extra to rid myself of Wilson or do i get a little extra and move Carr

[EAGLES]

I’d want Carr over Wilson, personally. I’d start with him and see what they say

[vixen]

I’d want Carr over Wilson, personally. I’d start with him and see what they say

i own Carr...i am the one that would get Luck