Trade advice-updated 9/28/2017

[tom14cat14]

Edited to new Offer


Give: Kelce
Get: my old 2018 1st and 2nd Should be top 4. Chance to be top 2.

[cptjonesb]

i think I would take option 3. In my mind that trade is Brown for Zeke which is close to even though I shade a little to Brown, but some might shade to Zeke as a 22 YR old RB1. And then you have 2 18 1sts for Kelce, which is a pretty good deal especially if one is early.

[Goddard]

Don't like the first two, but would definitely do the third one.

[HughHoney]

I don't understand option 2 vs 3. The difference is giving up Mixon and a first round pick for nothing. Why is 2 an option? Three looks pretty good though.

[Vcize]

Yeah I don't understand how options 2 and 3 co-exist either.

Anyway, take/offer option 3.

[Vcize]

Yeah I don't understand how options 2 and 3 co-exist either.

Anyway, take/offer option 3.

[tom14cat14]

Sorry everyone, I had his 2018 1st with the wrong trade. His is included with option 2 the mixon trade

[tom14cat14]

So the option we are still working on is 3. He wants to give Zeke and a 2018 1st that was mine. I tried for his 1st also and he said that is too much. I have counter my old 2nd but then said I cant do that since I am giving up 2 studs for 1 and a lot of risk in a pick.

[EAGLES]

Option 3 is your best bet, but, yes, you are getting the short end of the stick still.

Value wise
AB = Zeke (you may have to add a 2nd to AB here to even it out)
Kelce is worth more than just a late 1st

Since you’re rebuilding, try and get an additional side player to even out Kelce

[tom14cat14]

Option 3 is your best bet, but, yes, you are getting the short end of the stick still.

Value wise
AB = Zeke (you may have to add a 2nd to AB here to even it out)
Kelce is worth more than just a late 1st

Since you’re rebuilding, try and get an additional side player to even out Kelce

I will be getting my 1st back which looks to be top 3. And with this trade hard to see not being top 2.

[EAGLES]

Option 3 is your best bet, but, yes, you are getting the short end of the stick still.

Value wise
AB = Zeke (you may have to add a 2nd to AB here to even it out)
Kelce is worth more than just a late 1st

Since you’re rebuilding, try and get an additional side player to even out Kelce

I will be getting my 1st back which looks to be top 3. And with this trade hard to see not being top 2.

If it’s an early first, then yes take the trade

[tom14cat14]

Ok so we are now back to

Give Kelce
Get my old 2018 1st and 2nd

Quick thoughts before I accept. I think it has to be a top 4 pick. Bad thing is I will be starting CJ as of now at TE next year. But I think I am at least 2 years out. Might move Brown at some point.

[Coogan Football]

Is your edit correct above now?

If so I would do #3 in a heartbeat

[tom14cat14]

Is your edit correct above now?

If so I would do #3 in a heartbeat

The edit above is correct. 1st and 2nd for Kelce.