Melvin Gordon+ or Kareem Hunt?

[freddog97]

team 2 in sig

Give Kareem Hunt
Get Melvin Gordon+2018 1st(4-8)

[Generic Username]

Goodness...2 good games and he's separated himself from Gordon at a distance of a mid-1st? I'd call them even, no way I'd add to Gordon to get Hunt

EDIT...read that wrong, I'd accept quite quickly

[Sou1Ca1iber]

Gordon is still well above a rookie that is 2 games in. First should be on the other side.

[SteaminWillieBeamen]

Instant accept

[lukkynumber13]

Gordon is still well above a rookie that is 2 games in. First should be on the other side.

X2

[EAGLES]

Accept it and hope that 1st it lands at the 4 spot, just making this trade even sweeter

[Vcize]

I'll be the contrarian here. There's no way I'm touching Gordon for any top 10 dynasty asset, much less Hunt.

People are blinded by fantasy with Gordon. He looks well on his way to his 3rd straight sub-4ypc season again this year. No RB in the modern era has ever started with 3 straight seasons failing to break 4ypc and then retained their job in year 4.

I wouldn't be the least bit surprised if Gordon is part of a RBBC or even replaced by this time next year. There were already rumors of SD being interested in CMC this past offseason.

The perception is that Hunt is the risky one in this deal, but I think the reality is that Gordon is more risky.

[HughHoney]

I'll be the contrarian here. There's no way I'm touching Gordon for any top 10 dynasty asset, much less Hunt.

Much less? Meaning you view Hunt near the very top of the dynasty assets? Like top 3? Number one overall? I like Hunt a lot but let's not get carried away. Give me Gordon and a top pick in next years class.

[tyson]

I'll be the contrarian here. There's no way I'm touching Gordon for any top 10 dynasty asset, much less Hunt.

Much less? Meaning you view Hunt near the very top of the dynasty assets? Like top 3? Number one overall? I like Hunt a lot but let's not get carried away. Give me Gordon and a top pick in next years class.

I think it was not intended that way, though i could be wrong. he may be in the 10-12 range at the moment though

[pierson242]

Gordon

[cornhole2412]

I'll be the contrarian here. There's no way I'm touching Gordon for any top 10 dynasty asset, much less Hunt.

Much less? Meaning you view Hunt near the very top of the dynasty assets? Like top 3? Number one overall? I like Hunt a lot but let's not get carried away. Give me Gordon and a top pick in next years class.

I think it was not intended that way, though i could be wrong. he may be in the 10-12 range at the moment though

Top 10-12 overall? Or top 10 RB? His ADP was around RB 28, and theres still about 13 or 14 RBs I'm putting ahead of Hunt right now. But his arrow pointing straight up.

[LaFleur42]

This post makes me what to see if I can steal Melvin and an 18 first for Hunt...and I love Hunt!

[The Red Rooster]

This is one of those trades I would hate to receive if I owned Hunt...you almost have to take it but I wouldnt feel good about it (i.e, I would be hesitant). We dont really know what we have in Hunt yet...for all we know he is the next DJ...or he is the next Rawls. If you can use that extra first to pair with your own first and move up in the 2018 draft for a stud, I like it a lot more.

[Vcize]

Much less? Meaning you view Hunt near the very top of the dynasty assets? Like top 3? Number one overall? I like Hunt a lot but let's not get carried away. Give me Gordon and a top pick in next years class.

I think it was not intended that way, though i could be wrong. he may be in the 10-12 range at the moment though

Top 10-12 overall? Or top 10 RB? His ADP was around RB 28, and theres still about 13 or 14 RBs I'm putting ahead of Hunt right now. But his arrow pointing straight up.

If startup drafts were going on today Hunt's ADP would be in the 1st round.

[nyterp]

I think it was not intended that way, though i could be wrong. he may be in the 10-12 range at the moment though

Top 10-12 overall? Or top 10 RB? His ADP was around RB 28, and theres still about 13 or 14 RBs I'm putting ahead of Hunt right now. But his arrow pointing straight up.

If startup drafts were going on today Hunt's ADP would be in the 1st round.

Really? There are three no brainer 1st round ADP backs in Bell, Zeke, and DJ. I am digging around trying to find something that would indicate Hunt would be in their league in terms of ADP after two games and I can't find anything. I'm taking Gordon and the first here and not looking back.