A.Rob for Cook?

[WhiskeyRacer]

Hey all,

Let me just preface that I'm a Viking homer and have my purple shades on after Cook lit it up on his first pro game Monday night. Been watching him for a while and got him in at 1.03 in my rooking/FA draft this year, but I would have taken him 1.01 if I had that pick.

For the team in sig, I got offered Allen Robinson and a 2018 4th for my Dalvin Cook...

I'm just looking for some opinions on this offer after the big week 1 changes: A.Rob tore up his knee and Cook looked like a stud on a team that was surprisingly good on their home opener.


Thanks,

[EAGLES]

I think Cook looked good as well but he was facing the Saints. I think this is a fair trade BUT with your team in sig, I'd hold Cook. You need RB help way more than WR help

[Goddard]

This one's tough for me as I've been high on both of them for a long time. I think your team needs Cook a lot more right now, but I usually tend to go with the WR when I value two players evenly (a week ago, I would have gone Arob easily).

[Slackalacker]

I would say go for it, but that would essentially strip away your only young RB. Due to that I would not make the trade.

[RGKID144]

Hey all,

Let me just preface that I'm a Viking homer and have my purple shades on after Cook lit it up on his first pro game Monday night. Been watching him for a while and got him in at 1.03 in my rooking/FA draft this year, but I would have taken him 1.01 if I had that pick.

For the team in sig, I got offered Allen Robinson and a 2018 4th for my Dalvin Cook...

I'm just looking for some opinions on this offer after the big week 1 changes: A.Rob tore up his knee and Cook looked like a stud on a team that was surprisingly good on their home opener.


Thanks,

Regardless of team makeup, you should be able to net a whole lot more for DC at this moment in time. He has the makings of a first or second round startup pick next year while Arob seems to be falling into obscurity. He will be a FA in the offseason, and will need to rehab, and learn a new offense, etc. It's not out of the question for Arob to return some value, but your asking price should be much higher when trying to move a dynamite young piece like DC.

[Hahaclintondix]

Keep Cook. Another game like his first will see his value skyrocket above the current Arob value. That being said, I am a huge fan of buying up injured studs if I'm not a top 3/4 team. Depends where you think you're at.

[Vcize]

Cook >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> ARob

[Spongehack]

I wouldn't even consider this trade if you're a true Viking fan, especially with your RBs.

[WhiskeyRacer]

I wouldn't even consider this trade if you're a true Viking fan, especially with your RBs.

HA! This is pretty much what I thought when I received the offer, but thinking about the what-ifs was getting to me a bit. Glad to see that it doesn't look like I have my blinders on and can't see "value" with the A Rob offer.

[joekuhns11]

Cook cook cook, Arob keeps burning me and I'm tapped out

[moishetreats]

Hey all,

Let me just preface that I'm a Viking homer and have my purple shades on after Cook lit it up on his first pro game Monday night. Been watching him for a while and got him in at 1.03 in my rooking/FA draft this year, but I would have taken him 1.01 if I had that pick.

For the team in sig, I got offered Allen Robinson and a 2018 4th for my Dalvin Cook...

I'm just looking for some opinions on this offer after the big week 1 changes: A.Rob tore up his knee and Cook looked like a stud on a team that was surprisingly good on their home opener.


Thanks,

Regardless of team makeup, you should be able to net a whole lot more for DC at this moment in time. He has the makings of a first or second round startup pick next year while Arob seems to be falling into obscurity. He will be a FA in the offseason, and will need to rehab, and learn a new offense, etc. It's not out of the question for Arob to return some value, but your asking price should be much higher when trying to move a dynamite young piece like DC.

1,000%.

[Avery]

I like A. Rob but you have to account for an entire year of production lost in this trade. I think people tend to look too far out in dynasty as looking more than 2 to 3 years has too many factors to predict.

Given that window you're be getting no production for 33% - 50% of that window.

Keep Cook.