Give Kamara + 19 3rd + 20 3rd for J. Charles or Woodhead + 19 1st + 20 1st

[dynastyfanatic]

So. Owner is coming at me for Kamara. I traded for him + pieces after the draft with a late 1st next yr.

I don't like much on his team but hes offering this. My Team 1 in Sig.

Either Charles or Woodhead + his 19 1st + 20 1st for Kamara + 19 3rd + 20 3rd.

His team is a dumpster-fire and should still be early picks for both of those years. His best player is Joe Mixon.

His next best player is Jordan Matthews...not kidding.

Thoughts?

Team 1

[Goddard]

Charles, Woodhead, and the 3rds are completely valueless. This is basically Kamara for a 19 and 20 1st. I'm not sure Kamara is worth two 1sts, but because they're so far out, I'd probably pass.

[Mike from Canada]

I'd take two early firsts for Kamara. It doesn't bother me that they're far out. I think I know why his team is a dumpster fire.

[Shoreline Steamers]

With the depth you've already got at RB, and the fact that Kamara is still an unknown I think I'd make this trade but only for Woodhead. I'm really doubting that Charles even makes the Bronco's roster. And if he does his role likely won't be significant. Those knees seem to be about shot.

As Goddard notes I'm not sure many people value Kamara as worth two 1st's. So if you can get them, why not take them and enjoy the benefit down the road. Your team is set to compete this year anyway without any contribution from Kamara at all.

[Kramer]

With your RBs and only needing to start 2RBs, I would easily take the two 1sts here.

[Space Cowboy]

Charles, Woodhead, and the 3rds are completely valueless. This is basically Kamara for a 19 and 20 1st. I'm not sure Kamara is worth two 1sts, but because they're so far out, I'd probably pass.

Yeah, hard to hit reject on that offer and I'm all about stockpiling picks but this is just too long to wait.

[FKC]

With your RBs and only needing to start 2RBs, I would easily take the two 1sts here.

X2

[Bisquiteen Trisket]

Id do it.

Id also make sure the commish collects the 2019 and 2020 fees from him upfront to ensure the league continues on. Those pick are worth zilch if the league folds because that team is worthless and cant rebuild.

[Spongehack]

Id do it.

Id also make sure the commish collects the 2019 and 2020 fees from him upfront to ensure the league continues on. Those pick are worth zilch if the league folds because that team is worthless and cant rebuild.

This. But usually both teams have to submit fees upfront in order to trade future picks.

[dynastyfanatic]

Id do it.

Id also make sure the commish collects the 2019 and 2020 fees from him upfront to ensure the league continues on. Those pick are worth zilch if the league folds because that team is worthless and cant rebuild.

This. But usually both teams have to submit fees upfront in order to trade future picks.

I'm not too worried. I'm the commish and we're all friends in the league. If he trades them away I get to keep them regardless of what happens to his team. Even dispersal. They may get slightly better but dispersal would still barely affect his roster.

[Plank]

Saints were 2nd in the League last year throwing to RBs ..

Saints face the 2nd easiest schedule of pass defenses allowed to RBs this year ..

Even with that, if this owners teams is in shambles I'd take his 1sts for the next few years ..

I'd also go after his 2nds before the season starts

[vixen]

With the depth you've already got at RB, and the fact that Kamara is still an unknown I think I'd make this trade but only for Woodhead. I'm really doubting that Charles even makes the Bronco's roster. And if he does his role likely won't be significant. Those knees seem to be about shot.

As Goddard notes I'm not sure many people value Kamara as worth two 1st's. So if you can get them, why not take them and enjoy the benefit down the road. Your team is set to compete this year anyway without any contribution from Kamara at all.

well thought out response. i couldn't agree more

[dynastyfanatic]

Yea I'm still torn. I know its a good deal. I am also a Saints fan and having what *appears to the be the future back there is enticing to me.

I play to have fun and owning Kamara is fun and those picks are not fun (right now) unless I could flip them for something now (which I would try). With the state of my team, I think having Kamara or those future picks is just a toss-up (return is so far down the line).

I would def. choose Woodhead over Charles and Woodhead would actually score more then Kamara this year so it even makes sense for my team now. I targeted Kamara after the draft so it feels counterproductive to give him back however.

I paid an 18 1st for him + some late 4th rnd fliers. So to get earlyish 1sts back but in 19 and 20 is a gain in return but just too far in the future.

My inner dialogue is killing me...Im leaning no unless he adds something to it (which he just told me he won't).

Thanks...