McFadden or Smallwood

[norcalmill]

I give McFadden

I Get Smallwood


what do you think?

[Fantasy>>>Reality]

been hearing smalwood is on the roster bubble.

[norcalmill]

me too. then today i hear he is starting in practices against the fins...and writers tweet they think he might be the token starter for the season....?? however none of that appears on the philly boards

[Spongehack]

Word on the street is Smallwood might be PHI starting RB. Depends if you are contending though. I would keep McFadden if contending. He will give you a good boost if Zeke is out.

[norcalmill]

im back to back defending champ looking to 3-peat....i tried to offer Hurns for Smallwood but got shot down and countered with this offer.

[bigbuck22]

Despite conflicting reports about Smallwood, I have to believe that if Blount is not the starter then there's a good chance that the starter isn't even on their roster at this time. I could see Ingram still being moved to Philly. Smallwood is not the answer.

[Space Cowboy]

All those eagles RBs are pretty bad. I'm avoiding all of them.

[Kramer]

Smallwood might never do anything. I expect Sproles to lead the backfield in touches regardless. Blount should get the short yardage work at least. Smallwood won't do anything noteworthy this year and I don't think he has the upside to do much in the future. He's more of a JAG who when given the opportunity would probably produce, but that opportunity will probably take multiple injuries. McFadden will at least give you 6 weeks of RB1 numbers. That has pretty good value for any contender. I'd take McFadden.

[Goddard]

For your team, I'd sell DMC for whatever you can get. If Smallwood is the best you can do, then go for it. But make sure you shop him around first.

[BigBawseRoss]

you should be able to easily get an overpay for mcfadden from someone

[RB6]

For your team, I'd sell DMC for whatever you can get. If Smallwood is the best you can do, then go for it. But make sure you shop him around first.

Agree with this.