Trade Involving Michael Thomas, McCaffery & Howard

[Bisquiteen Trisket]

PPR Scoring - 1QB, 2RB, 2WR, 2Flex, 1TE, 1DEF

Ive been negotiating with an owner back and forth for the past few days. The final offer he sent is:

I send: Michael Thomas, Kareem Hunt, Eddie Lacy, 2018 1st
I receive: Jordan Howard, Christian McCafferey, Kevin White, 2018 2nd

Notable players on my current roster:
QB - Winston, Dak
RB - Gurley, Fournette, Hunt, Lacy
WR - Thomas, Keenan, Davante Adams, Martavis, Moncrief, Funchess, Hurns
TE - Clay, Walford, Swoope, Gathers

Should I make the trade?

[Zhoward88]

I'd rather have Thomas side. Mccaffrey and Howard is nice, but I like Thomas and hunt with a first more.white and lacy don't mean much to the trade besides they both aren't reliable. Take the highly ranked WR and high ceiling RB with a 1st.

[cornhole2412]

Howard and CMC hold a ton of value, but I see Howard as a major regression candidate. Your giving up too much on your side. Plus you're not exactly stacked at WR and have solid RB starters. The overall value is probably there maybe even favors you but I'd be keeping the Thomas side.

[Chandler Bing]

Howard/CMC side

[J. Edgar]

Pretty fair offer and you improve your running back depth with potentially the best receiving RB that's come around.

[The.Big.Spank]

Thomas side for me. Hunt is a beast in waiting. I can't believe this is even close.

[EAGLES]

I voted Thomas/Hunt. Giving up Thomas would hurt your WR core. Your RBs are already solid. Hunt, who I think will be the starter sooner rather then later, and the '18 1st are worth keeping with your team.

[skip]

Howard is the best piece, imo. And I'd rather have McCaffery than Hunt. Though I like Lacy, I'd rather have those two pieces in this trade.

[Goddard]

Thomas, but it's close.

[Meretc01]

I would hold... I like your upside more.. hunt is starting yo look better

[Tripwired]

I'd porbably keep Thomas, Hunt, and the 1st rounder. I think it depletes your Wr's too much. Plus, Hunt looks legit. I think the value of the trade is fine all by itself, but losing your only true WR1 hurts. If keenan gets hurt again this year, which likely will happen, you're down to Adams and Moncrief as starters. Moncrief has injury issues of his own. Plus, losing the first rounder.....

[vixen]

I voted Thomas/Hunt. Giving up Thomas would hurt your WR core. Your RBs are already solid. Hunt, who I think will be the starter sooner rather then later, and the '18 1st are worth keeping with your team.

i agree...