Gurley+ vs. Hopkins+

[joeday]

12 team, PPR league, pick a side:

Give - CJA, DBooker, JCharles, DHenderson (yes, all 4 DEN RBs), Hopkins
Get - Gurley, Demaryius, late 2018 2nd.

[The Red Rooster]

I might value all of the DEN RB's as the late 2018 2nd...maybe? They are all definitely taking up roster spots and it would be nice to get something for them. So then Hopkins for Gurley and Thomas...I think its pretty even. To me it kind of comes down to if you like Hopkins or Gurley more.

[CooperCrush]

Agreed with above about Denver RB's being a 2nd so I see it as

Hopkins 2nd<DT and Gurley

[mclilj]

All the Denver RBs lol! Either you have the deepest rosters ever or you're a big team denver homer (me too).

But I think this is a good trade for you. I have no idea which denver rb is going to emerge. I like the value of booker and Henderson over CJA and jamaal but I'm not really confident and wouldn't want my roster clogged that much.

[joeday]

All the Denver RBs lol! Either you have the deepest rosters ever or you're a big team denver homer (me too).

But I think this is a good trade for you. I have no idea which denver rb is going to emerge. I like the value of booker and Henderson over CJA and jamaal but I'm not really confident and wouldn't want my roster clogged that much.

Haha they are 28 player rosters and we havent had to cut down post draft yet. I happened to have Charles already from his KC days, then got CJA and Booker in a deal then got Henderson in another.

[Favrezilla]

i like it it.

Gurley > Denver's lead back (probably CJ but who knows....)
Hopkins > DT+2nd...but not by as much

[BeeziBad]

Gurley side. I know DT is getting older but he's been so consistent. Sure owning DEN backfield is kinda nice but man that's too many roster spots, you might drop 2 of those guys in the coming weeks anyway.

[EAGLES]

Gurley/DT side for me as well

[joeday]

I got him to throw in James White for Sanu and I accepted.

[Goddard]

Don't really care for the Denver RBs and wouldn't want to roster all 3. I'd say DT and Gurley is slightly worth more than Hopkins.

[Fantasy>>>Reality]

totally depends who you like more; Hoplins or gurley? Nuk for me

[Bisquiteen Trisket]

Gurley + Thomas side for me. Obviously Gurley is better by mile than the watertrash that is Denver's backfield. I also think Thomas will outproduce Nuk over the next two seasons. Not saying he is more valuable in dynasty, but to a win now team he probably is. Consistently produces WR1/2 stats every year.