Watkins vs D. Henry+

[Dynasty19]

Just got a surprise offer in my team one below and it's a full PPR league..

Give: Sammy Watkins

Receive: Derrick Henry, JuJu and Malcom Mitchell

Thoughts??

[Fantasy>>>Reality]

I like Sammy. Love Henry but not big on JUJU and Mitchell

[AresGodOWar]

Sammy side easy not even close for me

[Shcritters]

Sammy

[Dynasty19]

He updated it to

Give: Sammy

Receive: Derrick Henry and Zay Jones

[topher]

Darn, because I liked the OP offer better. I'm really high on Henry and Juju though and not so much of Watkins. Hes a great player, just prefer the others obviously.

[AresGodOWar]

Darn, because I liked the OP offer better. I'm really high on Henry and Juju though and not so much of Watkins. Hes a great player, just prefer the others obviously.

Juju is never going to do much in that offence he really won't if Ben leaves , Henry is going to take another year or 2 to really get his chance as a lead back in Tenn.. Watkins is a superstar if he stays healthy and I mean like Julio type

[wildabeast49]

sammy still, need a difference making piece added onto Henry, not fliers who some people feel good about.

[Jmatt>Coleman]

He updated it to

Give: Sammy

Receive: Derrick Henry and Zay Jones

I don't trust Sammy to stay on the field. Could be the best player in the world but wouldn't matter if his lower body injuries don't stop. People might point to the fact that it takes 2 years for his injury to heal and he is ready to stay healthy, but the guy has the uncanny ability to get hurt and not play through injuries. Now add in getting traded to a crowded receiving group, not having time to learn the playbook or get on the same page, and having a pretty bad qb who might need a few more years to be ok. The Henry/zay side has some risk as well, neithers potential may come to fruition, but Sammy stock might go down further before it goes up.

The guy clearly wants Sammy though to be giving up those pieces so easily, as I wouldn't offer that. I would tell him to add a second round pick and the deal is done.

[DJB]

Its not really close to me. You have amazing depth with 3 studs at RB. I'd rather gamble on Sammy having a breakout year and his value will skyrocket.

[Goddard]

Pretty even for me.

[Rams Fan]

I voted Watkins. Like Henry but the other two don't close the gap for me.

[M-Dub]

I like the original offer better than the second. I like JuJu better than Zay straight up, so Mitchell is just gravy, assuming you have room for all three players on your roster.

[pierson242]

Sammy