Agholor for a pick

[norcalmill]

Proposed to me is i gt agholor and a 5th round pick 74th for my team below...its IDP so that plays a factor in the picks

i give 3rd round pick 47th...which my the 47th pick probably about 8-10 defensive players will be chosen so offensive player wise its like the 37th pick in a rookie/FA draft.

IDK for me its a little too rich...the pick i get back will be nothing more than taking a flyer on an UDFA or filling a position of need/depth on defense.

what do you all think...
side note i am an eagles fan and am aware of Agholors descent performance so far in camp...its encouraging but the guy has been a huge bust so far.

[Splinx]

Pass on that one! I'd maybe give a 5th to stash him, but that's about it. Some pretty good IDP should still b available with your 3rd rnd pick!

[dblj1199]

If you have a 5 rd rookie draft I think I'd be happy if someone gave me a 6 th rd pick for him. IMO he really has very little value currently.

[Goddard]

I'm passing too in an IDP.

[norcalmill]

thats what i felt but being an avid eagles fan and hearing some of the good things about him in camp. i wanted to bounce my thoughts on him off a more level headed audience.
but FYI talk is that he may run with the slot role...jordan mathews is a ???? at this time.

[songintheair77]

I'll pass. Agholor looks good, but the games don't count yet and he's never looked good when they have.

[surgebird2]

If you're interested in him, it wouldn't hurt to offer something like your 5th for him as mentioned above. He is getting a lot of hype, so it couldn't hurt to take a 5th round risk, especially since you're an eagles fan. Nothing's more fun than having players on your team you can always root for!

[AresGodOWar]

Year 3 breakout for him he already passed Smith on the depth chart and should be on the field a lot

[kingnesta]

I'd also take that deal. Has been the best player in camp which doesn't mean much, but I would rather take a chance on him. Matthews also has a gimpy knee.

[Maximus891]

Pass on that one! I'd maybe give a 5th to stash him, but that's about it. Some pretty good IDP should still b available with your 3rd rnd pick!

agree

[saw061600]

So the choice is get an IDP/offense lottery pick or take a chance on Agholor coming into his 3rd year (really 2nd NFL year since year 1 was Chip college offense). 47 in my IDP got you Golloday during weeks 1&2 after NFL draft. Doubt you get him there now.

Take the chance on Agholor.

[jginter1112]

I like Agholor. Hearing he has the slot all but locked up.

[vixen]

i think agholor had camp buzz every season...that being said, this is his 3rd year, so perhaps with a real WR1 on the team, he will find some success...i would probably take a chance.
however, as others have stated, you should counter with the 5th round pick...

[KenAndTonic]

I cut Agholor prior to the rookie draft and am starting to regret that with all the buzz. He went undrafted, so I may put in a speculative waiver bid on him to start the season, but I'm tempering my expactations for now. With Alshon and Torrey Smith both on 1 year deals though, it's enticing to think about - especially with Alshon's injury history.

If you can get the other owner to come down on their offer as others are suggesting, I would do it, but passing as-is.

[norcalmill]

update. ive tried with no luck to get agholor for less. offering a 5th and then offering a 4th.
However i did get the other side to throw in KJ Wright LB seattle with Agholor for this late 3rd round pick of mine. This 3rd round pick has a chance of hitting a good player but its more of a shot in the dark. often a top end LB would even be a target with that pick so to get agholor and wright im doing it.