Mike Williams or Jordy Nelson? Win Now

[Gtdano_14]

No indication that a retirement is imminent for Jordy. The gap is a first round pick. You can't just give away elite level numbers for so much uncertainty.

Agreed. As a contending team, I definitely have Jordy well ahead of Williams and would need at least a 2nd rounder to swap. If the team with Jordy is rebuilding, I can understand a straight swap knowing they take a hit in value now to get younger. Either way, Jordy is worth more.

[dlf4lyfe]

No indication that a retirement is imminent for Jordy. The gap is a first round pick. You can't just give away elite level numbers for so much uncertainty.

Agreed. As a contending team, I definitely have Jordy well ahead of Williams and would need at least a 2nd rounder to swap. If the team with Jordy is rebuilding, I can understand a straight swap knowing they take a hit in value now to get younger. Either way, Jordy is worth more.

I don't have my 2018 2nd anymore unfortunately. So I am going to start with Williams + 2018 3rd. If he tries to counter, I'll try to add a 4th, and my final fallback is Williams + 2018 1st but that feels like I am giving up too much.

[skip]

No indication that a retirement is imminent for Jordy. The gap is a first round pick. You can't just give away elite level numbers for so much uncertainty.

Agreed. As a contending team, I definitely have Jordy well ahead of Williams and would need at least a 2nd rounder to swap. If the team with Jordy is rebuilding, I can understand a straight swap knowing they take a hit in value now to get younger. Either way, Jordy is worth more.

I don't have my 2018 2nd anymore unfortunately. So I am going to start with Williams + 2018 3rd. If he tries to counter, I'll try to add a 4th, and my final fallback is Williams + 2018 1st but that feels like I am giving up too much.

What about offering Crabtree/3rd instead.

[Coogan Football]

I would not add much and not sure that I like the move for your team.

I'm not even impressed with Williams to be honest. Just not sure a yr or 2 of Jordy is worth it with that team.

x2

[dlf4lyfe]

Damn you Rotoworld.

http://www.rotoworld.com/player/nfl/12183/mike-williams

[dlf4lyfe]

Agreed. As a contending team, I definitely have Jordy well ahead of Williams and would need at least a 2nd rounder to swap. If the team with Jordy is rebuilding, I can understand a straight swap knowing they take a hit in value now to get younger. Either way, Jordy is worth more.

I don't have my 2018 2nd anymore unfortunately. So I am going to start with Williams + 2018 3rd. If he tries to counter, I'll try to add a 4th, and my final fallback is Williams + 2018 1st but that feels like I am giving up too much.

What about offering Crabtree/3rd instead.

I might have to now if he gets scared off because of the potential surgery. This owner has asked about Crabtree before too so that's a solid trade proposal to have up my sleeve, thanks Skip.

[psu007]

If you can get it, hell yes.