Pick a side of this big trade

[mmass]

Just made this trade in a Deep League QQRRWWWFFTTKKDD Team Deep 2 in sig

I got
Stafford Matthew DET QB;
Crowell, Isaiah CLE RB;
Peterson, Adrian NOS RB;
Cardinals, Arizona ARI Def;
Year 2018 Round 1 Draft Pick Early to Mid
I gave
Ryan, Matt ATL QB;
Cook, Dalvin MIN RB;
Gates, Antonio LAC TE;
Steelers, Pittsburgh PIT Def;
Year 2018 Round 2 Draft Pick Mid to late

Which side do you like and why?

[Kramer]

Ryan is roughly Stafford and AP. Cook is roughly the early to mid 1st with how the class is shaping up next year. I'm going to cancel out the defenses, even though you start 2. Then it's down to Gates and a late 2nd for Crowell in which case, I'd prefer Crowell even in start 2TE because of Gates' age and Hunter Henry breathing down his back. So I guess it's slightly in favor of what you got back. You will have to find another TE though.

[Goddard]

Ryan side by a good margin for me.

[The Red Rooster]

To me, this mostly comes down to whether you like Cook or Crowell more....I prefer Cook more but if that first ends up being a top 5 pick, I think this trade swings to your side.

[vixen]

i like your side by a fair amount

i think ryan=stafford
although i had cook as my RB2 in this rookie group, i still think that getting crowell, AP and 2018 1st beats cook and gates...

good move
btw: update your team in sig now

[jcc6fd]

Some posters saying Stafford and Ryan are close or equal in value but I don't think that's the case, especially in a 2QB league. I also prefer Cook to Crowell. The jump in the '18 draft doesn't close the gap for me. It's not awful, but I like the other side more.

[mmass]

How I saw it.

Ryan greater than or equal to Stafford " I feel Ryan just peaked and I get 3 years back with a similar QB.

Cook = Crowell... I am really starting to like Crowell s spot. Cook currently proved nothing and I got him with 1.09

Gates less than Peterson. I think Gates is on the back end of a timeshare and Peterson is on the front end of a timeshare. Both are at the end of their careers.

And obv early to mid first is better than a late to Mid 2nd.

[mmass]

Side not the team that got Ryan flipped him for Rodgers but giving up 3 seconds next year.... what a steal... wish I knew Rodgers was on the table.

[spotxc]

Ryan side for me. Ryan over stafford by a little margin. And cook + 2nd is better than crow/ap/1st. And gates is a decent throw in for a year