Pick a Side to End a Debate

[Bucky15]

Just a debate between a buddy trying to assess value. In a vacuum who are you taking? Julio and the 1.5 or the 1.2, Devonta, Diggs, and Abdullah?

[Bucky15]

Currently the results are what I expected (4-3) so it's a pretty even trade and more of a preference. He thought it was way off and I disagreed.

[Goddard]

Very close, but I'd give a slight edge to the Freeman side because it's younger and has the better pick.

[altball24]

I'd take the Julio Jones and 1.5 The pick is still a Top pick and has just as much potential as the 1.2 for this year. Any pick in the top 6 is interchangeable based on team needs and preference.

[Kramer]

This is tough but I think I'd rather have Mixon/Davis, Freeman, Diggs, Abdullah over Julio and Cook/CMC/Williams.

[DTMW78]

This is tough but I think I'd rather have Mixon/Davis, Freeman, Diggs, Abdullah over Julio and Cook/CMC/Williams.

X2.

[Dyno_7]

I think the trade is even depending on what each team needs.

[Dynastyallday]

Julio and 1.5 for me.

[skip]

Very even. I'd rather own Julio than all the players on the other side. But the 1.02 is slightly more valuable than the 1.05.

[M-Dub]

In a vacuum I voted for the 1.02 side, but it's close, and I wouldn't blame the Julio side for not wanting to add anything.

Outside of the proverbial vacuum, I could easily see a scenario where I'd prefer the Julio side, based on what he can do with those two extra roster spots. If it allows him to hang onto a couple young upside prospects that he'd otherwise have to cut or allows him to snag a couple players like that off the wire, that'd be enough to sway me to the Julio side. Never underestimate the value of an open roster slot.

[ttw9]

Pretty much agree with all the other posts. Close. The Freeman side is the route I would go. Proven RB and lots of upside

[jwint7910]

For me in a league with your starting requirements the depth of the freeman offer makes it the easy choice. Julio's health is a worry for me too.

[Shoreline Steamers]

Guess I'm in the minority on this one. But I much prefer the 1.2 Freeman/Diggs/Abdullah side.

Unless Julio starts scoring more TD's, I'd be happy with swapping him out for Diggs. Freeman is a very solid RB, and I'd prefer to have my selection of players at 1.2 as opposed to taking whomever falls to the 1.5. Abdullah is a big question mark, but worth a shot for 2017.

[Bucky15]

Perfectly good reasons for picking either side. Like I said the argument was that this trade was "horrible" and and not even close to fair from a value standpoint. I disagreed and thought it was very fair and almost an even "pick your preference" deal. Thanks all!

[SteveMaddensShoes]

Julio side slightly

Diggs=1.5
1.2, Freeman, Abdullah who equals an early 2nd/late 1st. So 2 early 1sts and a 2nd is slightly light for Julio.

I'm fine with it either way but Julio is the best player so I lean that way