D Henry for 1.05, 2018 1st

[Fantasy>>>Reality]

For team 1 in sig

Ive been offered the 1.05 and a 2018 1st for Henry. I just see such a perfect storm with that line, scheme and Henry into the future. Seems like a good offer though. I'm high on Henry so I need perspective. Wondering what you guys think?

[jcc6fd]

At 1.05 you're most likely getting Cook, an RB with similar draft pedigree in a better RB class with an immediate path to start. At worst he should be viewed as equally valuable to Henry. Then you add another first? I'd take the picks easily. Henry is a nice RB to own but he's being overvalued across the board

[HughHoney]

I prefer 1.05 to Henry. Snap accept for me.

[Brig]

For me personally I would take the deal because I am not high on Henry and I think Cook at Pick 5 and a future 1st gives you more.

[Dyno_7]

Pretty solid offer, but I'd probably decline it. Like you said, he's in an excellent situation and is most likely closer to a starting role than this year's 1.05 or the '18 pick.

[Goddard]

I think Henry is worth about the 1.05 himself, so you'd be getting a future 1st for free.

[ColdZealDonkeyStrike]

I like Henry over Cook, but the extra first would swing me toward that side.

[BuckeyeNation]

I like Henry over Cook, but the extra first would swing me toward that side.

Ditto for me.

[jeffster]

I like Henry over Cook, but the extra first would swing me toward that side.

Me too. Can always try to flip the 1.05 again if it is Cook that falls to you and you aren't a fan.

[pierson242]

I'm pretty high in Henry and I would take this deal

[smallxl]

On value alone I'd take the picks easy

[Bucky15]

Great value, instant accept for me.

[RASH]

I think that offer could go either way, initially I thought reject its selling Henry short (I have an addmitted bro crush on Henry's upside). But then stopped and I asked myself where I actually had Henry ranked in rookie value/picks... & personally I have him ranked ~equal to pick 1.02 (wouldnt accept less). So questuon now became, would I theoretically take a 2018 1st to move down from 1.02 to 1.05... & In this class its on the borderline for me, but end of day maybe/likely yes depending on who went 1.01 & if I thought I could get Cook at 1.05 (as I have him ranked as my #2rb peraonally). So short story long not a bad offer. But also not an instant accept in my book. Personal preference as to whether to accept or not.

[IR1]

Pretty high on Henry, but have to go with the picks, Henry could still be a year away from really taking over. same could be said about Cook but who knows who actually falls to 1.05

[Peteey84]

I love Henry but would take the picks I think.