Who should I give for Gurley?

[jojo5151]

For team 1 what's a good offer for gurleyman? I was thinking of pairing Moncrief with another asset to land him but struggling with who to pair him with, any ideas?

[jojo5151]

Bump

[Tripwired]

Imo it's hard to know who's best to package together unless we knew if the trade partner needs wr help, etc. What is the area of weakness of the other team? Knowing that allows us to piece together the puzzle.

[thomasscheeks]

If Moncrief is the best piece on your side I doubt anything gets done. Gurley is worth 20 Moncriefs

[Tripwired]

I would want, assuming Moncrief is the guy you want to move, your 1.10 & maybe even next year's first rounder since this year's is late in the round. That along with moncrief might peak my interest. Not totally sure I'd do that deal, but I'd look for sure.

[srlarson]

Moncrief, Cooper, Gillislee, and your 1.10 should get you in the ballpark......

If Moncrief is the best you want to give up.....agreed not going to happen.....need to give up one of your top 3 guys.

[Favrezilla]

If you were coming to me unsolicited you better bring a MUCH better offer than moncrief.

I'd expect alshon or Watkins and a pick or rb. It's probably not worth trading for him as you don't seem deep enough to give up the pieces to get him. I would trade him for any less than a top3 1st and one of the WRs I mentioned. But you might be lucky and find someone who's down on him.

[pierson242]

If I recieve an offer for my Gurley and Crief is the best piece I doubt I'd even counter. Your obviously trying to buy low on him. You don't have the depth to make a trade that doesn't hurt your team. Stay put

[TTHTD]

Keep Moncrief, selling now would be selling way low and he should regress upwards if healthy so his value should increase this year. If Gurley struggles or even does mediocre again, which seems like a real possibility, he'll be way cheap next season. He's being drafted as the rb4 in most cases so that's a pretty high bar to reach and if he doesn't his value will recalibrate downwards. Especially if one or more rookies breakout which they inevitably will.

[Pet_Smith]

Best offer I had for Gurley was 2018 1st & 2nd, 2019 1st and 2nd plus Perkins. If they were for '17 ans '18 picks instead I'd have taken, but not going to give a valuable piece to someone in my sub-league with nothing to show for this year (I don't rate Perkins).

If I was offered Moncrief - I'd hope he was the sweetener, not the main piece of the pie - Gurley owners still holding to high hopes!!

[skip]

Bump

[Goddard]

Moncrief, Cooper, Gillislee, and your 1.10 should get you in the ballpark......

If Moncrief is the best you want to give up.....agreed not going to happen.....need to give up one of your top 3 guys.

Cooper alone is worth much more than Gurley.

[Goddard]

I'm thinking Moncrief, McCoy (assuming he would want a RB in return), and maybe the 1.10.

[jojo5151]

Thanks guys for the input. I agree Cooper alone is worth way more than Gurley but i understand I'll have to give up another piece. I'm guessing knowing the owner it would take Monciref, my 1.10 & possibly McCoy but that might be too much given what I've seen so far. Shady has a couple really good yrs left in him so I'm leaning towards staying put. I have to hope Jstew or Gillislee carry a big load & yes depth is my weakness hence the trade idea.

[thomasscheeks]

Thanks guys for the input. I agree Cooper alone is worth way more than Gurley but i understand I'll have to give up another piece. I'm guessing knowing the owner it would take Monciref, my 1.10 & possibly McCoy but that might be too much given what I've seen so far. Shady has a couple really good yrs left in him so I'm leaning towards staying put. I have to hope Jstew or Gillislee carry a big load & yes depth is my weakness hence the trade idea.

If you can trade Shady and Moncrief for Gurley you should hop on that. I agree that McCoy will likely outscore him this year, but it probably won't be by much. This might be your last chance to get Gurley for a steal like that.