Luck for Landry - 0.5 ppr / 1 QB League

[MattyBee]

Hi All,

I have the chance to acquire Landry for Andrew Luck in the 12 angry men league in my sig. He won't budge. Do you think it's worth it?

Thank you

[pierson242]

1QB and you still got Mariota, yes please

[MattyBee]

It's the other team mate, I have Rivers and Tyrod as back up!

[pierson242]

It's the other team mate, I have Rivers and Tyrod as back up!

Sorry it's early for me! I would still do it! Rivers and Tyrod are both great QBs. In my formats Tyrod was only a few spots behind Luck in total point. I'd still make the deal

[MattyBee]

Thanks for the advice mate!

[trc]

Yeah - solid trade.

[dhanks91]

Landry loses a bit of his value in a .5 ppr, but I'd still take the deal

[The Red Rooster]

Landry loses a bit of his value in a .5 ppr, but I'd still take the deal

Agreed.

[joker4]

It's the other team mate, I have Rivers and Tyrod as back up!

Even better. I'd definitely do it as you have two quality players that can play qb for you, however I might try and trade Tyrod for a comparable starter

[Pac_Eddy]

I'd stick with Luck. It's easier to get a WR in Landry's range than to get a QB in Luck's. In five years, you'll look back on this & regret going for Landry.

I realize I'm in the minority here.

[Oddball456]

In my 10-teamer 1 QB league I wish I could get Luck for something like Landry. I have gone after Wilson, Mariotia, and Winston (the teams also have Dak, Brees, and Cam, respectively) and trying to use Snead or JMatt or Cam Meredith along with Eli so they have a good back-up, and an extra piece (solid LB2). None would even consider it. the Carr owner (also has Stafford) says that my 1.4 pick this year would be required to be part of the deal to get Carr. Guess I will just stick with Eli this year.

Edit: the Luck owner in my league also has Brady, so I might try to trade one of the WR for Brady, but he said that trading away Luck would take "a lot".

[The Red Rooster]

In my 10-teamer 1 QB league I wish I could get Luck for something like Landry. I have gone after Wilson, Mariotia, and Winston (the teams also have Dak, Brees, and Cam, respectively) and trying to use Snead or JMatt or Cam Meredith along with Eli so they have a good back-up, and an extra piece (solid LB2). None would even consider it. the Carr owner (also has Stafford) says that my 1.4 pick this year would be required to be part of the deal to get Carr. Guess I will just stick with Eli this year.

Edit: the Luck owner in my league also has Brady, so I might try to trade one of the WR for Brady, but he said that trading away Luck would take "a lot".

That's because Landry is far more valuable than the WRs you are offering. You are offering a sum of parts by tacking on Eli and a LB2...none are great on their own. It's like offering bench players for a starter.

[Goddard]

Landry is worth more than any QB in a 1QB league.

[ADrunkenCaveman]

In my 10-teamer 1 QB league I wish I could get Luck for something like Landry. I have gone after Wilson, Mariotia, and Winston (the teams also have Dak, Brees, and Cam, respectively) and trying to use Snead or JMatt or Cam Meredith along with Eli so they have a good back-up, and an extra piece (solid LB2). None would even consider it. the Carr owner (also has Stafford) says that my 1.4 pick this year would be required to be part of the deal to get Carr. Guess I will just stick with Eli this year.

Edit: the Luck owner in my league also has Brady, so I might try to trade one of the WR for Brady, but he said that trading away Luck would take "a lot".

That's because Landry is far more valuable than the WRs you are offering. You are offering a sum of parts by tacking on Eli and a LB2...none are great on their own. It's like offering bench players for a starter.

Exactly.. Dont know how he can say its the same ballpark lol.

Give me Landry.
I wouldnt trade Luck for anyone under Landry though I dont think.

[thomasscheeks]

Landry by a mile