KA or Baldwin/1st?

[jnappy]

Which side would you rather have? Team 3 in sig.

[spotxc]

Baldwin / 1st is a nice haul for K allen..Keenans value has dipped due to injury and draft

[Cowboysfan33]

I'll take the Baldwin/1st side. Although, not flashy, Baldwin has had two solid years in a row now and gets a bunch of targets and he hasn't missed many games either. Even though he is older than KA, adding that 2018 1st would easily make up the difference between those two players, imo.

[skip]

I'd rather have Baldwin than Keenan.

[Lime]

I don't trust KA and apparently neither do the Chargers (see Mike Williams). There are way too many options in that offense with Rivers who is not far from retirement. That doesn't even count the health issues. Baldwin is a WR that you can put in your #2 slot and not worry about, he gives you a safe floor every week and has 20+ point weeks as well. The additional first round pick accounts for the difference in value if Keenan Allen somehow actually reaches his upside.

[Goddard]

Where's the 1st projected?

[jnappy]

Where's the 1st projected?

Hard to tell, we just finished our startup. I'd guess mid-late.

[FiremanEd]

I'm taking Baldwin and the 1st. While older, Baldwin is a baller WR2 with WR1 upside. He's on a downward value slope, but the 1st will be the opposite. Keenan Allen now has a very crowded depth chart that almost arruredly means lower volume (all of Tyrell, Henry, and Mike Williams have come on or come aboard since he was producing), while also having injury concerns and an aging QB. Another injury, or low production, and things magnify and his value begins to fall aggressively. I get the youth and upside piece, but he's not riskless. I think Baldwin will be his equal for a few years anyway.

[Knox Steel Curtain]

I like Baldwin alone in this deal better so easy choice for me.

[Alex116]

Where's the 1st projected?

Wouldn't matter to me. Could be a 30 team league with it being the 1.30 and i'd still take it! Lol. KA and his injuries scare me more than some. I get it, some were of the "freak" variety but some dudes, for whatever reason, just can't stay on the field and that's pretty important to FF.

[pierson242]

Baldwin and the 1st here for me

[PercyR1]

keenan side if its 1.9 or later 1st
Baldwin side if its 1.1-1.8

[eraldo_coil]

I'd take Baldwin over KA straight up so the 2018 first is just gravy

[curtisn16]

Baldwin and first for me

[M-Dub]

I'm a Keenan owner and I still believe, but I'd take that package pretty easily.