CMC offer

[NY CAT]

I was just offered the following for Christian McCaffrey.

2018 1st round pick, W. Gallman, M. Mack and C. Coleman.

Thoughts.

[joshuawrobbins]

As long as you have roster space I'll take the first side

[Generic Username]

Sold! But, I'm not high on CMC and prefer hoarding WRs

[Alex116]

I like Coleman enough for him to swing that side to my liking.

[pierson242]

I would take the Coleman side

[Goddard]

I'm not very high on the pieces on the other side, so unless the 18 1st is projected to be early, I'd pass.

[smallxl]

I'll pass as well. Need something better than Coleman

[whodunnit]

I would take this trade. I think Mack will develop nicely in Indy if he can become more comfortable between the tackles and put on a little size (shouldn't be a problem) and Coleman himself is the best WR on his team. and that 18 1st could be better than McCaffrey.

[TTHTD]

I'm pretty high on CMC, but this is a pretty decent deal. I think it's fair value and which side I took would depend on team needs.

[BuckeyeNation]

It's pretty close for me, but I am a Coleman fan. I'm not saying Mack/Gallman are worthless, but in the context of this trade I'm looking at CMC against Coleman/'18 1st, with the other players just being icing. I'd probably take the package, but roster space and where I projected the '18 1st would play a role in my decision.

[Honey Badgers]

I'm taking the package. But I am a big Mack fan.