Alshon worth 2 future firsts?

[AndrewS]

Is Alshon (and his injury history) worth a 2018 late first (9-12) and a 2019 mid-late first (6-12)? For team 1 in my sig i'm tempted to add him to AB/MT/Cooks but I also like that i currently have multiple first round picks the next two years. What do the experts say?!!!

[jwb32]

I'd pull the trigger. Sure, there is some injury risk but he's still in his prime (only 27). I take the gamble that he stays mostly healthy and produces high WR2 numbers for the next 3-4 years.

[Novacane]

That would be a steal for alshon. Has this been offered or are you thinking of offering? I would be shocked to see an alshon owner let him go for a 2018 and 2019 first.

[joshuawrobbins]

I doubt you can get him that cheap. But if you can I definitely would be all over that

[Goddard]

I wouldn't give up Alshon for that, but if you're buying, then yes.

[Generic Username]

You have no RBs in a start 2 format...unless you haven't updated sig to include high profile rookie RBs from this year, I think you'd be better served keeping your picks and selling AB at some point before season's end

[Cabana]

Give me Alshon easily

[Honey Badgers]

Alshon all day!

[IR1]

Alshon side for me

[Sgtpsych]

The future firsts are too late.

[lukkynumber13]

He's worth 2 random 1sts in the 2017 class. He's definitely worth an 18 & a 19.

[jwint7910]

You have no RBs in a start 2 format...unless you haven't updated sig to include high profile rookie RBs from this year, I think you'd be better served keeping your picks and selling AB at some point before season's end

This is kinda what I was thinking. I'm not an Alshon guy. I could just as easily see him fading from the scene and taking another prove it deal as I could see him regaining high end WR2 value.

I don't really think your team has the stuff to compete at the top end. In you shoes I blow it up, but I really enjoy that type of rebuild.

[colonnaj94]

I think if you need a WR badly enough he could be worth 2 firsts. I've personally just never been a huge fan of his, he's too much of a headache..Always seems to be hurt & was suspended last season..

[eraldo_coil]

Even if you're not an "Alshon guy" you have to take this... Either ride him as Philly's WR1 or resell him, but you can't not take this deal.