Poll: Ingram/Lewis vs Lacy/Yeldon

[FiremanEd]

How do you view the following two sides, and what do you feel should be added to one or the other if anything?

Side 1: Mark Ingram + Dion Lewis

Side 2: Eddie Lacy + TJ Yeldon

Worth noting that one side has Rawls/Prosise and Kamara, while the other has Peterson and James White as well.

[Goddard]

I went with Even, but I think I'd rather have Lacy. If healthy and in shape (similar to the start of last year), Lacy should outscore Ingram.

[harr]

I'd rater have the Ingram side, but think it's pretty close.

[knuckles50]

Pretty close but I think Ingram's role is same as last year whereas Lacy is in a very crowded backfield.

[Kramer]

I'd rather have Ingram than Lacy and would rather have Lewis just as a dark horse that gets an opportunity somewhere outside of NE than Yeldon who will be limited by Fournette.

[FiremanEd]

Thanks for the responses and votes. My initial thought is that Ingram > Lacy but with the uncertainty of Lewis that Yeldon is the safer player for at least some slight contribution in case of emergency. I still don't mind him if you can wait until his contract is up and he departs. The Jags OLine hasn't generated much for anyone and he may fair better with a change of scenery if you wait. His stock is low now as well. Ideally I can get an extra value boost on top so wanted to discuss the mass opinion given all of these players have a level of uncertainty with their value with recent movements (them and depth chart).

[joshuawrobbins]

I went with the Ingram side basically because he has a safe floor. Even with Peterson and Kamara, Ingram should see a decent work load. I would not be surprised if Lacy does turn into a TD machine, health permitting. Such a close poll. If I could revote I think I'd go with even.

[HawkeyeState]

Ingram- Should still be a productive player, don't think old AP takes much of his touches honestly. Kamara should zap most catches from Ingram.
Lewis- No way to predict if he will even play each week. I suppose you can hold him and hope he gets cut and goes to a better team/depth chart. if he stays a Patriot, I'm not sure how he gets you anything.

Lacy-If he can be healthy/weight under control, he should eat in Seattle.
Yeldon-Fournette doesn't have amazing ability to catch the ball and that's an area Yeldon does well in.

I think it's very likely with the factors above that Lacy and Ingram score similarly this year, possibly Lacy more points.
I think your guaranteed at least some PPR upside with Yeldon, and I don't think your going to get anything from Lewis.

For those reasons, I'll take Lacy and Yeldon