Rank these Rookie RBs...

[brewster]

How do you rank the following in PPR scoring?

Foreman
Kamara
Mack
JoeWilliams

Feel free to elaborate. I'm looking at mainly 2nd round rbs (based on rookie drafts) and I have them pretty close to each other so curious to see what you guys think.

[Warriors09]

Joe Williams - for the purpose of recent news. Albeit this kid might not even on a roster next year as he might retire.
Mack - Due to Gore and Turbin
Foreman - Think he replaces Miller in a year or two
Kamara - Dont know his role yet. And really unsure of his abilities due to small sample size of work.

[onetwothree]

Joe Williams - for the purpose of recent news. Albeit this kid might not even on a roster next year as he might retire.

He "quit" for awhile due to stress from the passing of his sister. I don't think that should be held against him.

[pierson242]

Joe Williams - for the purpose of recent news. Albeit this kid might not even on a roster next year as he might retire.

He "quit" for awhile due to stress from the passing of his sister. I don't think that should be held against him.

Agree


As for me

Foreman- will be a great back and take over as a full lead back in a year or two
Kamara- ton of upside don't know his role though
Williams- 49ers love him and they have Shanahan bonus points
Mack- Good but not great back with a good but not great situation

[Kramer]

Foreman- will be a great back and take over as a full lead back in a year or two
Kamara- ton of upside don't know his role though
Williams- 49ers love him and they have Shanahan bonus points
Mack- Good but not great back with a good but not great situation

I agree with this. Foreman is going to be good sooner rather than later. Watch out Lamar Miller.

[Goddard]

Kamara, Foreman, Mack, Williams (and I like Williams).

[dblj1199]

Williams- Shannahans wanted him, he makes rb's fantasy stars
Mack- only has a 34 yr old rb ahead of him, has the passing game to free up the box
Foreman- could easily take over as lead rb after this season
Kamara- tons of upside, crowded backfield, could emerge next year as lead rb

[brewster]

Thanks for the opinions guys! Any other thoughts out there on these guys?

[Dizzle]

I'd put Mack on top. He may be starting by year end.
Same with Williams. But Mack is on better offense.
Then I'd go Foreman and Kamara.

[Servo]

From a talent perspective, not dependent if they'll be an immediate player:

1. Foreman
2. Williams followed by Mack
3. Kamara.

[bigbuck22]

Kamara
Mack
Williams
Foreman

[drbuttermaker]

1) Williams--love his game and his situation
1a) Mack-love each slightly less

Distant 3) Kamara--like his game...the Saints backfield, not so much.

No Thanks) Freeman--his ball security is going to kill his career if he does not fix it. Someone else can take that risk.

[sharkattack]

Kamara

Foreman
Williams

Mack

[BowHunter186]

How do you rank the following in PPR scoring?

Foreman
Kamara
Mack
JoeWilliams

Feel free to elaborate. I'm looking at mainly 2nd round rbs (based on rookie drafts) and I have them pretty close to each other so curious to see what you guys think.

Kamara, Williams, Mack, Foreman.

[TTHTD]

How do you rank the following in PPR scoring?

Foreman
Kamara
Mack
JoeWilliams

Kamara - Intriguing long term value/small, high draft capital invested, size = small upside though?
Foreman - Decent draft capital invested, but Miller is too talented to become irrelevant anytime soon. I see a CJA/Booker style RBBC happening here. Upside is high though

Mack- Gore has to break down eventually... right!?

Williams - JAG some beat writers are hyping because Shanny reached for him 3 rounds too early. I'd be look to sell in the offseason to a nervous Hyde owner.