Should I make this trade?

[Hambone]

12 tm PPR, BUT RBs get an extra .25 per carry so they carry more value and we need to start 2. My team:

Winston
Gurley, McCaffrey, D.Henry, Gio, Yeldon
A.Brown, Cooks, Watkins, C.Davis, Ty.Williams
Kelce, Engram

I have an offer where I can basically trade McCaffrey and Davis for Evans (some smaller pieces mixed in). Now, in a league where RBs don't get an extra bump, it'd be a no brainer. But given the bump here, plus I'm not exactly stacked at RB, should I pull the trigger?

[Missile]

Easy accept

[Hambone]

Easy accept

Normally I would agree, but you don't think the RB bump plus not being loaded at RB is enough of a deterrent? I'd be looking at starting Henry or Gio on a weekly basis..any injury to Gurley and I'd be screwed.

[Goddard]

Very easy accept. McCaffery isn't going to be getting 20 carries a game. Evans would still be a top 5 player, even in that setting.

[IR1]

Take the stud

[Missile]

Easy accept

Normally I would agree, but you don't think the RB bump plus not being loaded at RB is enough of a deterrent? I'd be looking at starting Henry or Gio on a weekly basis..any injury to Gurley and I'd be screwed.

How many carries do you envision McC getting each week? Might get you an extra 3 points or so. Evans for 2 rookies is still a steal imo even with the format.

[Hambone]

Easy accept

Normally I would agree, but you don't think the RB bump plus not being loaded at RB is enough of a deterrent? I'd be looking at starting Henry or Gio on a weekly basis..any injury to Gurley and I'd be screwed.

How many carries do you envision McC getting each week? Might get you an extra 3 points or so. Evans for 2 rookies is still a steal imo even with the format.

I guess I'm just worried about my RB depth. This league is difficult to trade for RBs, and I don't have my 1st next year either. But I know it's a great deal either way

[Kramer]

Evans by a lot even in this league

[The.Big.Spank]

The extra point Evans will score should me up for the extra points the Rb would get.

[smallxl]

Take the proven guy and don't look back

[ZachAttack]

Evans.

[zelldawg26]

That's a steal. The chances of either player having anywhere near Evans' value is not very high. Mike Evans is practically neck and neck with OBJ. I would take that in a heart beat and enjoy the ride.

[sevendust33]

im going to say no in this scoring format by slim margin but if you did would be fine with it i think evans numbers r going to go down some more mouths to feed with djax howard plus they still have barte and drafted godwin . I think evans is still a stud but the more weapons team has could cut into some production. mccaffrey even if he only gets 12 carries a game will catch 3 or 5 every game also on top of the carries. To me comes down to how much u believe in davis long term if u r sold on him as a top 20 wr which i think he can be in a year or 2 then no and thats why i vote no

[AresGodOWar]

I would try to get Zek for that even though in a RB bonus league it will be impossible..

Maybe take the Evans offer if you can get a elite RB for him

[23B_Mills]

Very easy accept. McCaffery isn't going to be getting 20 carries a game. Evans would still be a top 5 player, even in that setting.

x2