Richard Mathews vs Kevin white

[lunchbox12]

Which would you rather have (.5ppr)

[Golly Dagger]

Kevin White. Upside is much higher despite injury history.

[IR1]

Probably personal preference, I'd roll the dice on White, IF he's healthy could be a true WR1

[0crush83]

Kevin White. Upside is much higher despite injury history.

Agree. I don't think it will happen, but I'd prefer to take the chance on it then go after a WR4.

[saw061600]

Kevin White. Upside is much higher despite injury history.

Agree. I don't think it will happen, but I'd prefer to take the chance on it then go after a WR4.

RMatt was 22nd in PPR last year. That on a team that ran first but expects to pass more (not GB/NE level, but more still), with a rookie QB, and add he will no longer be drawing the top DB. I think projecting him as a WR4 is a bit much.

[Kramer]

White for me too.

[Goddard]

White, but it's close. Don't really like either though

[slacker]

Gimme the guy that will be healthy when I need to plug him in. Mathews.

[pierson242]

Yea gimme Mathews. Him and Mariota click he's still gonna be a dependable flex guy

[Shcritters]

White. Suddenly too many WRs in Tenn and white has high upside.

[Igwebuike 4 Prez]

I value real production over perceived value, so give me Matthews. He has something White doesn't: chemistry with a good young QB.

White had one year of elite production in college and has done almost nothing in the NFL. Upside doesn't hold as much water coming up on age 25 with that resume. His upside didn't include 2 seasons lost to injury.

[The.Big.Spank]

Kevin White. Upside is much higher despite injury history.

Agree. I don't think it will happen, but I'd prefer to take the chance on it then go after a WR4.

X2

[Ravenous]

too bad we can't vote for "none". The case against matthews is b/c they drafted two WRs that had decent pre-draft rankings. What does that say about their belief in matthews for the future?
I agree that white has the upside....but the WR corps in Chicago is just as in the air as TEN. Meredith and White probably the most upside...but we don't know if how glennon/tribusky are going to be used. I wonder if kendall wright might be the value here on the short passing game.

[Crwdstunna]

For me it comes down to upside and I think White has much more of it over Matthews. Take White unless you absolutely just don't think White can amount to anything.

[Terrierlefty]

For me it comes down to upside and I think White has much more of it over Matthews. Take White unless you absolutely just don't think White can amount to anything.

Agree with this. I would take white though.