Ingram or Cobb (poll)

[theWilkman]

In the wake of the AP news, choose one for team in signature. I only need to start 1 RB.

[Favrezilla]

INGRAM by quiet a lot.

cobb is at best 3rd on the pecking order and outside of Jordy it will be hard to depend on any one receiver (marty b / DA / Cobb) and Ty who will catch a lot of passes out of the backfield.

only packer id be looking to acquire is Rodgers.

[pierson242]

INGRAM by quiet a lot.

cobb is at best 3rd on the pecking order and outside of Jordy it will be hard to depend on any one receiver (marty b / DA / Cobb) and Ty who will catch a lot of passes out of the backfield.

only packer id be looking to acquire is Rodgers.

Oh let the AP Frenzy begin. APs washed up talent doesn't scare me at all! It's really just the saints lack of confidence in Ingram. However, Cobb for Ingram straight up isn't even freaking close. Everything favrezilla said is spot on. Not to mention if they draft another RB

[theWilkman]

INGRAM by quiet a lot.

cobb is at best 3rd on the pecking order and outside of Jordy it will be hard to depend on any one receiver (marty b / DA / Cobb) and Ty who will catch a lot of passes out of the backfield.

only packer id be looking to acquire is Rodgers.

Considering he's my WR 6 it's probably a good deal for my team, as I don't have much after the Dallas RB spot. At this point in the season I'm more concerned with value in my trades, I'll sort out starting requirements later. I wanted to see how much the AP signing was affecting Ingram's value in the eyes of the community. Prior to this news I would've taken the deal for a straight swap

[pierson242]

INGRAM by quiet a lot.

cobb is at best 3rd on the pecking order and outside of Jordy it will be hard to depend on any one receiver (marty b / DA / Cobb) and Ty who will catch a lot of passes out of the backfield.

only packer id be looking to acquire is Rodgers.

Considering he's my WR 6 it's probably a good deal for my team, as I don't have much after the Dallas RB spot. At this point in the season I'm more concerned with value in my trades, I'll sort out starting requirements later. I wanted to see how much the AP signing was affecting Ingram's value in the eyes of the community. Prior to this news I would've taken the deal for a straight swap

I agree! That's what I was getting at, you should be trading away Cobb for Ingram in a heart beat

[BuckeyeNation]

I just made this same trade in a league where I too was stacked at WR and short on RBs other than Zeke. I sent Cobb and got Ingram. I actually sent the offer several days ago before the AP news, and forgot all about the offer until the other owner accepted yesterday when the AP signing broke. Even after AP signing, I think it's probably a toss-up.

[Tyrober]

Ingram > Cobb. I'm still a believer in Cobb but Ingram is a stud when he gets the ball. AP signing is curious and he very well might vulture some TDs but I like still Ingram here. This isn't a no brainer trade and is relatively close if Cobb bounces back but I think you made a solid trade.

[saw061600]

Cobb is a buy low. Getting Ingram is a nice sell high, great win.

[Goddard]

I'm still going Ingram.

[theWilkman]

Thanks for everyone's input