NON PPR: Melvin, Kelvin or Shady, Keenan, 1.9

[joeday]

In a NON PPR, 12 team league, which side do you prefer?

Give - LeSean McCoy, Keenan Allen, 1.9

Get - Melvin Gordon, Kelvin Benjamin

[Goddard]

Shady, allen side

[colinhunt13]

Not big on Benjamin so I'll take the shady side

[dynastysports]

Not big on Benjamin so I'll take the shady side

I agree with this. I was a big buyer on Goron last offseason because I thought he had a big season in him. However I am not a big Kelvin guy so even though I am not a big Keenan guy the value is on the Shady Keenan side. If you can get the pick dropped or get a better WR back then Kelvin I'd pull the trigger. Even if the first was a 2nd I'd probably pull the trigger.

[skip]

Tough one. I prefer KB over Allen but the McCoy/1.09 to Gordon. Looks even.

[joeday]

If I took the WR part out of it and it was Shady and 1.9 for Gordon would that be a good move?

[Edgy68]

I like it for you. You get a younger workhorse back by giving up a pick in what seems to be a questionable range.

[Favrezilla]

i think im leaning to MG3/KB side. if this is for team 2 in your sig then id probably do that.