1.01 for Allen Robinson straight up?

[roofy61]

I've been offered 1.14/1.15 and 2018 1st for the 1.01. It is three firsts but feel like it's not enoughas the picks are so late.Was going to counter for Robinson and maybe 1.14?16 team IDP PPR. Would you take Robinson straight up or ask for a bit more.

[Kramer]

ARob over 1.01 straight up for me, so yes.

[BLuHeeLR]

ARob > 1.01 all day. But it doesn't hurt to ask for more. I assume this is a 16-team league? Studs are hard to come by in a deep league like that. I'd ask for for ARob + 2017 2nd and that 2018 1st. You need the extra juice to deal a stud in a deep league.

[schiewerma21]

I got Allen Robinson the 1.07, tevin Coleman AND a 2018 first for the 1.01 just a few weeks ago!

That being said... I would have taken just Arob. Arob slightly over 1.01 for me

[pierson242]

I got Allen Robinson the 1.07, tevin Coleman AND a 2018 first for the 1.01 just a few weeks ago!

That being said... I would have taken just Arob. Arob slightly over 1.01 for me

Trade rape!

But yea I would take Arob + over the 1.01

[lukkynumber13]

If you can get anything on top of ARob for the 1.01, then congratulations you're a winner.

Please don't forget to tip your dealer!

[Goddard]

Agree. Arob for me as well. However, that first offer was so terrible that I doubt your trade partner gives up ARob for the 1.01.

[Vcize]

I'll take 1.01 over Braylon Edwards V2 any day.

[SteveMaddensShoes]

The dude isn't being serious about acquiring the 1.01 it doesn't seem. Or maybe he is just hoping you don't know better. I'd say Arob and the 2018 1st. My guess is he won't even counter since he was never legit.

[Cameron Giles]

There's been so many different versions of this trade asked over the offseason. Robinson for 1.01? Hopkins for 1.01? Gurley for 1.01?

Take the proven talent. Rookies have the advantage of no NFL sample size. That means we've never seen them have an underwhelming season. All we have are thoughts of upside and potential dancing in our head. But the second they underachieve (and they will), there will be threads asking about trading them for the next new toy with no sample size.

[Chandler Bing]

I would take ARob over 1.1 but it's close

[saw061600]

I got Allen Robinson the 1.07, tevin Coleman AND a 2018 first for the 1.01 just a few weeks ago!

That being said... I would have taken just Arob. Arob slightly over 1.01 for me

I wouldn't have taken that trade but only because I'd have had an excitement induced heart attack before getting to my computer to accept.

Arob over the 1.01 but, as others have said, try for some more since he's kind of a buy low to many after last season.

[bot]

piling on for ARob

[Vcize]

There's been so many different versions of this trade asked over the offseason. Robinson for 1.01? Hopkins for 1.01? Gurley for 1.01?

Take the proven talent. Rookies have the advantage of no NFL sample size. That means we've never seen them have an underwhelming season. All we have are thoughts of upside and potential dancing in our head. But the second they underachieve (and they will), there will be threads asking about trading them for the next new toy with no sample size.

ARob is not really proven. There is a lot of risk there. These guys that have a down year early in their careers very often never come close to regaining the value they once had.

Braylon Edwards, Trent Richardson, Doug Martin, etc. All "proven" guys who combined for 1 more good season between the three of them after they hit their "slumps".

[Cameron Giles]

ARob is not really proven. There is a lot of risk there. These guys that have a down year early in their careers very often never come close to regaining the value they once had.

Braylon Edwards, Trent Richardson, Doug Martin, etc. All "proven" guys who combined for 1 more good season between the three of them after they hit their "slumps".

You forgot another one: Calvin Johnson. Oh, wait.

Braylon Edwards is an idiot, Trent Richardson had a ton of off-field issues that caused his decline and Doug Martin has way too many injuries. But, here's a list of players who had at least 80 receptions, 1400 yards and 10 touchdowns in one of their first three seasons:

Jerry Rice
Sterling Sharpe
Isaac Bruce
Randy Moss
Larry Fitzgerald
Demaryius Thomas
A.J. Green
Odell Beckham
Deandre Hopkins
Allen Robinson

Feel free to play against the talent and the odds, especially when we know the reason he had a down season is mostly on his QB. A 23-year-old WR with a WR1 season is a lot more proven than any rookie.