WHO WON THIS TRADE?

[smallxl]

1 - pt PPR

[Cherokee]

Its a good trade for both teams most likely. Even in my eyes

[23B_Mills]

I think it's even, but I'd rather receive Jordan Howard.

[Vcize]

Howard by a lot.

[IR1]

I'm high on Howard and not a Pryor believer, Howard side for me

[Pac_Eddy]

Howard side easily. I'm not a believer in Pryor.

[lukkynumber13]

In most leagues I would probably take the Howard side as he's PROBABLY the best asset in the deal. But if the settings literally only allow for ONE single RB to start weekly, then give me Hyde & Pryor

[GridironGuerilla]

In most leagues I would probably take the Howard side as he's PROBABLY the best asset in the deal. But if the settings literally only allow for ONE single RB to start weekly, then give me Hyde & Pryor

I totally get this point, but I'd much rather go int a season with Howard as a backup to DJ in case of injury or bye week than Hyde. He drops off pretty quick after that. This trade basically gives you two RB1's as insurance to get to the playoffs.

[captain caveman]

Surprisingly close. If Hyde stays healthy for a whole season he puts up comparable numbers to Howard + td upside.

[Vcize]

There are no guarantees, but Howard just had an OBJ-like rookie season that mostly only all-time great RBs were able to match as rookies.

Meanwhile as a Hyde owner I'm extremely worried he doesn't make it past the end of April without a major hit to his value.

[btv802]

Well count me as one of the weirdos that would def prefer the Hyde & Pryor side.

[Vcize]

Players to rush for 1200+ yards as a rookie.

Fred Taylor
Chris Johnson
Ladainian Tomlinson
Matt Forte
Steve Slaton
Marshall Faulk
Adrian Peterson
Jamal Lewis
Eddie George
Doug Martin
Mike Anderson
Curtis Martin
Clinton Portis
Edgerrin James
Alfred Morris
Ezekiel Elliot
Jordan Howard

P.S. Howard did it in 13 games.

[Goddard]

I'd rather have the Howard side.

[Novacane]

Meanwhile as a Hyde owner I'm extremely worried he doesn't make it past the end of April without a major hit to his value.

I feel like this part doesn't get talked about enough with Hyde. Everyone is so gaga over the Shannahan impact that they forget that Shanahan has not always rolled with the perceived starter. One of the beauties of his system is that you dont need a great back to put up great numbers. This is especially a concern for an oft-injured back who becomes a free agent next season.

If they do take a back in the first 2 days, I think hyde's value will drop significantly. If they grab a later back, he could be a sneaky good stash.

[smallxl]

In most leagues I would probably take the Howard side as he's PROBABLY the best asset in the deal. But if the settings literally only allow for ONE single RB to start weekly, then give me Hyde & Pryor

You can start 2rb to clarify