this is why calcs dont work

[sloth8u]

i just figured that i'd throw this in the team advice forum for the offseason.

i receive...luck
i give... dak, martin, graham

with a kind letter from the co-commish telling me how fair this is via the calculator.

[IR1]

Yep, calculators let nickels, dimes, quarters add up to a dollar. I do use them occasionally when it's 1:1, 2:2 type deals just to "double check"

[skip]

The minute a reference to a trade calculator enters trade talks, the discussion is basically dead.

[Ryantacular]

I would rather have Luck here. No joke.

[vbbish]

I would rather have Luck here. No joke.

I was thinking the same thing... I actually would prefer the Luck side here

[GridironGuerilla]

Me three.

[Favrezilla]

I would rather have Luck here. No joke.

ME TOO...Seems like the calc does work here.

[RocketDr]

Took me a minute to grasp what happening here, but yeah that's not even close. Luck way overvalued as far as I am concerned.

[sloth8u]

I would rather have Luck here. No joke.

this is exactly the point. no matter how even qb scoring is/or isnt (in a few owner's opinions) you should never get caught up in this. the difference between 375 and 400 is not martin and graham when it comes to qbs

[mudster]

As much as I'd like to see Luck become the second coming of Dan Marino, I just don't think the Colts are going to let that happen. He's getting killed on a weekly basis and it won't take long before his potential gets beaten out of him. I still like him more than Prescott straight up, but the 3 for 1 is a joke. Bad calculator, bad...get off the counter.....

[auggiedoggies]

Luck side and it's not close at all for me

[LaDarius]

Piling on for the Luck side.

[SpartacusPTech]

If I was rebuilding I would consider the Dak side. But assuming that's Doug Martin and Jimmy Graham. Martin's value is rapidly declining. Jimmy Graham had a nice bounce back year, but I don't see him sustaining those stats. Unless this is a TE premium league, you can replace Jimmy easy.

I'll take the Luck side here and thank the Commish for the gift of the offer.

[onetwothree]

Not a fan of 3 for 1 type deals when I'm receiving the 3. Means I probably gave up the best player in the deal AND I have to figure out 2 guys to waive to bring in the extra pieces. Would have to be something where I get 1.50 back for my 1.00 since I can probably find a couple dimes on waiver wire.

[Stabsinthe]

Calculators are only useful when they show the trade is in your favor.