Hyde vs multiple picks

[koenigfj]

12 team PPR league- have decent depth at RB , however right now Hyde would be starting RB for me. Looking to get some fresh blood for WR/TE.

Get: 2017 1.08 2017 2.08
Give: Hyde, 5.10

Think I can add something extra? (thinking about Malcolm Mitchell, Perriman)...any thoughts are welcome, pretty torn on this.

[cd6696]

I voted for the picks because that's what I'd take for Hyde but I think you can likely get a bit higher pick for him. That what I think the posters below me will say.

[foogeq9]

That's what I'd take for Hyde but I think you can likely get a bit higher pick for him.

[greenbird]

Hyde side for me

[koenigfj]

Thanks all-am countering with additional 2nd rd asks and see if he bites on this.

[thomasscheeks]

Hyde. He's really good and the 9ers should get better with the moves they're making

[The.Big.Spank]

I like Hyde here. If the niners get Cousins, Hyde moves right into RB1 talk.

[auggiedoggies]

Hyde easily for me.

[koenigfj]

thanks everyone-super helpful

would you change your perspective if this would look like
2017 1.08, 2.05, 2.08 plus Malcolm Mitchell for Hyde?

[Valhalla]

That's what I'd take for Hyde but I think you can likely get a bit higher pick for him.

Well played

[Balzac]

thanks everyone-super helpful

would you change your perspective if this would look like
2017 1.08, 2.05, 2.08 plus Malcolm Mitchell for Hyde?

That is much closer, but for me I would want a higher first as the starting point. Hyde is an RB1 no doubt. Remember that he was the top prospect of his class, and if he can get in a full season with a half way decent team around him he should live up to that.

[Jason3123]

I am officially on the Hyde bandwagon. Traded Doctson and some picks for him last week. I would much rather have Hyde over the 1.8 and 2.8.

[LaFleur42]

That's what I'd take for Hyde but I think you can likely get a bit higher pick for him.

If I had Hyde I wouldn't take anything less than a 1.05?

[Valhalla]

I'd offer up 1.5 probably. I'm not sure what rb you are going to get at 1.5 that walks into a starting role. Hyde's offense sucks, but he's the main carrier, young, and has proven he can run effectively at the NFL level. That's worth something.
He does get injured a lot...but if he didn't get injured a lot he'd easily be worth more than 1.5. It's the injuries that lower his value, not his talent.

[theone]

thanks everyone-super helpful.... 2017 1.08, 2.05, 2.08 plus Malcolm Mitchell for Hyde?

This is far too much for me. I like Hyde as a nice 2 down runner but I like the RBs in the 1.5-1.7 range far more than Hyde due to their more complete games. Hyde issues include his injury history, bad OL, unknown QB situation, is practically worthless in the passing game, and has unknown future as a FA after 2017.