Which offer do you like better?

outrage · Postby **outrage** » Tue Mar 23, 2010 8:46 pm

I'm looking to upgrade my RBs, and have 2 possible offers.

Offer 1:
Boldin + F.Jackon for Rice + P.Thomas

I offered this to him, and he said he needs to think it over. It seems like a win-win. I get a very solid 3rd RB in Thomas, and Boldin to Rice is pretty much a push (or an upgrade to some).

Offer 2:
Boldin + Barber + 1st for MJD

He offered this to me. I'd be set at RB with MJD, Stewart, and Moreno. I can afford to lose Boldin since I'm pretty loaded at WR. Losing the 1st (1.08) hurts a bit, but it's not really a big deal.

Both seem like solid offers to me, but I just don't know which I like better. Offer 1 potentially gives me 2 upgrades and I don't lose any depth in the process, while offer 2 gives me a stud (something I don't really have).

I think I'm leaning towards offer 1, but of course I'm waiting to see if he'll do it or not. Should I wait to hear his reply, or just accept offer 2? Thoughts?

Shawn · Postby **Shawn** » Tue Mar 23, 2010 8:51 pm

Accept offer #2 ................................. NOW!!!!!!!!!!!!

outrage · Postby **outrage** » Tue Mar 23, 2010 8:53 pm

Shawn wrote:Accept offer #2 ................................. NOW!!!!!!!!!!!!

Haha. I've been VERY tempted... trust me.

There's also another possible offer I've been talking over with another owner. I won't go into details (don't want to complicate things), but this 3rd offer would compliment offer 1 much better.

pvballer3915 · Postby **pvballer3915** » Tue Mar 23, 2010 8:54 pm

ACCEPT OFFER 2. id give that for MJD in a heart beat. Bolden is good but u can afford to lose him. Barber wil lbe the #2 rb in denver. And a 1st for MJD. hes a top 4 dynasty rb. Take that deal IMO

Deal 1: Fred Jackson >>> PT (i see jackson as the #1 in buff) and i like bolden more than rice. who knows what rice will be when favres gone!

thewhyterabbit · Postby **thewhyterabbit** » Tue Mar 23, 2010 8:54 pm

outrage wrote:
Shawn wrote:Accept offer #2 ................................. NOW!!!!!!!!!!!!

Haha. I've been VERY tempted... trust me.

There's also another possible offer I've been talking over with another owner. I won't go into details (don't want to complicate things), but this 3rd offer would compliment offer 1 much better.

what # is that 1st? regardless, id still take MJD.

outrage · Postby **outrage** » Tue Mar 23, 2010 8:56 pm

thewhyterabbit wrote:
outrage wrote:
Shawn wrote:Accept offer #2 ................................. NOW!!!!!!!!!!!!

Haha. I've been VERY tempted... trust me.

There's also another possible offer I've been talking over with another owner. I won't go into details (don't want to complicate things), but this 3rd offer would compliment offer 1 much better.
what # is that 1st? regardless, id still take MJD.

1.08

pvballer3915 · Postby **pvballer3915** » Tue Mar 23, 2010 8:58 pm

ima say it again....ACCEPT IT LOL

Postby **SpaderDude** » Tue Mar 23, 2010 9:37 pm

I've tried to overpay for MJD time and time again to an owner that really needs to rebuild and he refuses. Take it now.
MJD all the way!!!

outrage · Postby **outrage** » Tue Mar 23, 2010 9:40 pm

How important is Jennings as a handcuff. Do I need to somehow get him in this deal?

Postby **skip** » Tue Mar 23, 2010 9:45 pm

Offer #1 is in your favor as most have Rice ahead of Boldin or at best that is a push. And PT is definitely more valuable than Fred Jackson.

Offer #2 is a fair price to pay for MJD. If you can afford to make this move, its a solid one.

Have you considered combining the offers like this:

Boldin, Barber, Fred Jackson, and the 1.08 for MJD and Rice ? I'd even kick in a little more from your side if you can make it happen.

outrage · Postby **outrage** » Tue Mar 23, 2010 9:48 pm

The offers are from different people. Sorry I didn't specify.

jimmo · Postby **jimmo** » Tue Mar 23, 2010 9:56 pm

outrage wrote:How important is Jennings as a handcuff. Do I need to somehow get him in this deal?

Not that important. Nice to get but not a deal breaker. Deal 2 is an easy one to make. Deal one is also a pretty nice trade for you. Anyway to to swap out Boldin in one of the two and do both?

Postby **skip** » Tue Mar 23, 2010 10:03 pm

jimmo wrote:
outrage wrote:How important is Jennings as a handcuff. Do I need to somehow get him in this deal?
Not that important. Nice to get but not a deal breaker. Deal 2 is an easy one to make. Deal one is also a pretty nice trade for you. Anyway to to swap out Boldin in one of the two and do both?

Ah, nice idea... I'd see if the guy in offer 1 wants Nicks instead of Boldin.

outrage · Postby **outrage** » Tue Mar 23, 2010 10:04 pm

jimmo wrote:
outrage wrote:How important is Jennings as a handcuff. Do I need to somehow get him in this deal?
Not that important. Nice to get but not a deal breaker. Deal 2 is an easy one to make. Deal one is also a pretty nice trade for you. Anyway to to swap out Boldin in one of the two and do both?

With Colston, probably, but I don't think I'd do that. Wouldn't really need Pierre.

BradyT · Postby **BradyT** » Wed Mar 24, 2010 1:58 am

Deal #2 is ridiculous.. it should´ve been accepted in the very first second you saw it...

Dynasty League Football Forum

Which offer do you like better?

Which offer do you like better?

Who is online