Would you make this Zeke trade

[gbpckrs]

I have zeke and have been offered the 1.03, 19 1st, and Mixon. I also have the 1.02 and the 1.06. Should I ask for more, I think its a fair deal for zeke, I could get 2 RBs in this years draft and grab a WR with the 1.06. What do you guys think?

1QB, 2RB, 3WR, 1TE, 1 RB/WR/TE/, 1K, 1DEF


Here is my roster

[hudini33]

You should ask for a lot more

[bills2]

Dang it, I was hoping this was the person I sent a Zek trade to earlier today. Was going to say yes real fast.

For this trade, I think you should be able to get a proven player, but I'm not as high as most on Mixon.

[kellysheroes]

not really close

[cvbuc]

You can get 3 unproven players where historically and statistically speaking...
One will be very good but not as good as Zeke
One will be an average starter that you'll spend a lot of time trying to upgrade
One will bust and be worth a 3rd or lower within 2-3 years.

Or
You can keep a stud top 4 RB for the next 5+ years.

If you're going to trade a premiere stud - you HAVE to get back a premium player that has proven his potential in addition to high picks.

[thomasscheeks]

Pass for me. You should be able to get a lot more than that for him

[JDogil12]

You can do better

[playa_hata]

i think you can do slightly better but a lot more is an over statement mixon and 2 firsts one of them an early first most likely landing you guice/penny/chubb and a 19 first i would look to get something proven swapped for the 19 first unless that 19 pick is going to gauranteed be the 1.01 so mixon, guice/penny/chubb, and lets say jarvis landry,diggs, thielen would be a deal

[FantasyFreak]

IDK, I think that can be parlayed into quite a bit. I see Mixon and Zeke as high risk players for off field issues. There is a ton of Mixon love in the community, though. There are some people who would trade Melvin Gordon for Mixon for some weird reason. MG went in the 3rd round of a 14 team SF/TE premium League I just did, while Mixon went in the 2nd. Penny/Guice, Mixon and a future 1st is pretty good. I would definitely want to be sure I could flip Mixon, but if I could do it for a guy like Gordon or Fournette (who I have seen go after Mixon in startups), I'd do it, on the contingency I could set up a good trade for Mixon.

[mmass]

IDK, I think that can be parlayed into quite a bit. I see Mixon and Zeke as high risk players for off field issues. There is a ton of Mixon love in the community, though. There are some people who would trade Melvin Gordon for Mixon for some weird reason. MG went in the 3rd round of a 14 team SF/TE premium League I just did, while Mixon went in the 2nd. Penny/Guice, Mixon and a future 1st is pretty good. I would definitely want to be sure I could flip Mixon, but if I could do it for a guy like Gordon or Fournette (who I have seen go after Mixon in startups), I'd do it, on the contingency I could set up a good trade for Mixon.

Please do tell about these of the field issues Mixon has.... Hmmmm.... this is a reach

[BradysBunch]

I think it is close ( if you like mixon), but I am still keeping Zeke.

[NFL-ons]

Don't take a wr at 6.

[crusty tubesox]

this is a hard pass for me...laughable really.

[Farley]

this is a hard pass for me...laughable really.

It's hardly laughable.

The value is on the Zeke side but people are being ridiculous to say this is that far off. Probably off by a mid-1st.

It goes without saying that it's a rebuild move. And your roster is not a rebuild.

[crusty tubesox]

this is a hard pass for me...laughable really.

It's hardly laughable.

The value is on the Zeke side but people are being ridiculous to say this is that far off. Probably off by a mid-1st.

It goes without saying that it's a rebuild move. And your roster is not a rebuild.

i shudda maybe reworded that to boarderline laughable... but to me a mid 1st is alot no matter what yr it is.... and if u think the offer is off by a first thats borderline laughable
just one mans opinion