Thielen or 1.05?

[doug040]

RB needy team. 1QB league. Thielen would still be a full-time starter. Thielen or 1.05?

[Chwf3rd]

I think that's fair value for Thielen

[Johnny Canuck]

I'd prob rather have 1.05 but it would depend on who is left on the board, and my roster breakdown. Pretty fair trade imo.

[coldfusion167]

I'd take the 1.05.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Gimme 1.05. I value Thielen around 1.08.

[Z$$$]

1.05

[vixen]

if you are getting 1.05 for Thielen, then take it
if you are getting Thielen, try to get a late 2nd early 3rd (even if 2019)..i would value him over DJ Moore, probably below the RBs

[Ice]

I traded 1.2 and 2.9 for Thielen, Mack, and 2.3.

The traded Thielen for Parker and 1.11 Gallup.

Theilen is a good player to trade. My take is his upside is around 85 catches so on value I would take 1.5 but would want a bit more like a 2nd. A lot of owners value him quite a bit. He is a polarizing player.

I ultimately turned 1.2 & 2.9 into Parker, Gallup, Mack and Gesicki and Theilen was a big part of that transaction. He has poker player value but I think he is a sell type due to situation.

[vixen]

I traded 1.2 and 2.9 for Thielen, Mack, and 2.3.

The traded Thielen for Parker and 1.11 Gallup.

Theilen is a good player to trade. My take is his upside is around 85 catches so on value I would take 1.5 but would want a bit more like a 2nd. A lot of owners value him quite a bit. He is a polarizing player.

I ultimately turned 1.2 & 2.9 into Parker, Gallup, Mack and Gesicki and Theilen was a big part of that transaction. He has poker player value but I think he is a sell type due to situation.

interesting you put names on your picks, who were the players taken at 1.02 and 2.09?
i think i would rather 1.02/2.09...
Parker has been a hyped up each year and then disappoints
Gallup... i own him in one league, so i am not going to jinx anything
mack...not sure if he can handle the load, or if he has that job next season
Gesicki...see Gallup above

[bainer3]

Wish Thielen got a few more tds, would make this an easy choice lol but I’d say even in 1 ppr, any other format I’d rather the 1.5.

[Ice]

I traded 1.2 and 2.9 for Thielen, Mack, and 2.3.

The traded Thielen for Parker and 1.11 Gallup.

Theilen is a good player to trade. My take is his upside is around 85 catches so on value I would take 1.5 but would want a bit more like a 2nd. A lot of owners value him quite a bit. He is a polarizing player.

I ultimately turned 1.2 & 2.9 into Parker, Gallup, Mack and Gesicki and Theilen was a big part of that transaction. He has poker player value but I think he is a sell type due to situation.

interesting you put names on your picks, who were the players taken at 1.02 and 2.09?
i think i would rather 1.02/2.09...
Parker has been a hyped up each year and then disappoints
Gallup... i own him in one league, so i am not going to jinx anything
mack...not sure if he can handle the load, or if he has that job next season
Gesicki...see Gallup above

Penny went 1.2 (who I would have picked) Hayden Hurst 2.9

Didn't really need a RB but needed to get younger at WR and TE.

I am high on Gallup and Gesicki both of who I rated number 1 at their position in this draft well before the NFL draft and both went to good situations. Mack is a sleeper pick for me. Like his size and burst. He could finish top 12 this year in fantasy. Not much competition.

I get Parker has been an accident looking to happen since drafted but his upside is really high. Needs to stay healthy for sure. I am well aware of Parker's history.

The RB's are a bit overvalued this year IMO. Like a lot of them but after 1.1 the entire first round of this draft could flip as the talent is really close. Its only a $75 league so don't mind risk but each player I acquired has significant upside.

[vixen]

i actually liken the RBs to last year's crop...i think all will be valuable and starters...difficult to predict which will be the Kamara of the group...
i don't think that is overvalued at all though...i just think it is difficult who will be most valued next season..

[Trevormortis]

1.05 for me

[jessup45]

I’m in the minority here but give me the 8th overall ppr WR last year. If I needed the RB more or if I was deep enough at WR were Theilen wasn’t a starter I couldn’t fault anyone for wanting the 1.5 more. That said, if he’s my starter, I rather start him this year over Chubb, RoJo, Michel.

[Ice]

i actually liken the RBs to last year's crop...i think all will be valuable and starters...difficult to predict which will be the Kamara of the group...
i don't think that is overvalued at all though...i just think it is difficult who will be most valued next season..

Not overvalued if you pick the right one! There are a few 2 down backs going pretty high IMO. Kind of my point. The difference from 1.2 thru 2.3 are the tightest I have seen in years in fantasy.