Poll: Derrick Henry or 1.05 non-PPR

[gratefulydead3]

Changing of votes is allowed. If you choose Derrick Henry please put what first round selection you would need to move him. Just trying to see where people have him compared with these rookies

[Jason3123]

Henry about to have a career year so I’d want either Guice/Barkley. I like Chubb more but considering his injury history I would just rather have Henry’s solidified role in Titans. He should easily have 220+ carries this year.

[skip]

I value Henry at or above the 1.02, so unless the trade was 1.01 or something added to 1.02, I'll take Henry.

[Bot101]

Id take Henry over the 1.05. Henry is 1.03 and lower for me.

[Cowboysfan33]

I'd take Henry over the 1.05 in non-PPR. He’s going to get alot of carries but I don’t think he’ll play much on 3rd down. It’s definitely concerning that they brought in D.Lewis and paid him pretty well too. In non-PPR that shouldn’t matter as much though.

[gratefulydead3]

Henry about to have a career year so I’d want either Guice/Barkley. I like Chubb more but considering his injury history I would just rather have Henry’s solidified role in Titans. He should easily have 220+ carries this year.

What has me wondering is the heavy contract just given to Lewis. They're going to want yards for those dollars, and I'm just curious why they would pay that much when you could find a similar player on day 2 or even 3 if you're lucky. I like Henry as a runner at 1.02. But with Murray and now Lewis taking away from his production, I'm trying to shake the feeling I'm looking at another Jonathan Stewart.

FWIW my vote is Henry

[Shoreline Steamers]

Henry in non-ppr. He'll share with Lewis, but I think it's likely he gets the short yardage and goal line carries that matter most in the format. I don't think you're getting a player at 1.05 that will do what Henry can.

[guyatwork37]

I'd take that pick all day. Henry is trash and Dion Lewis got paid to have a significant role. Henry won't be doing anywhere near what people here seem to think.

[kadun2]

Id take Henry over the 1.05. Henry is 1.03 and lower for me.

X2

[Cameron Giles]

This isn't close for me. Henry's potential in a non-PPR league is a lot bigger than whatever you're getting at 1.05.

[treble83]

I'd take that pick all day. Henry is trash and Dion Lewis got paid to have a significant role. Henry won't be doing anywhere near what people here seem to think.

I'm definitely not a Henry hype man but seriously!? He won a Heisman less than 3 years ago!

D. Murray was a diva and Mularkey bowed to his demand to be the "feature back." Henry has now shown enough for Vrabel not to make the same mistake.

[treble83]

To answer OP, I would need the 1.02 and I would only take it if I wasn't a Henry believer..

[FantasyFreak]

Henry about to have a career year so I’d want either Guice/Barkley. I like Chubb more but considering his injury history I would just rather have Henry’s solidified role in Titans. He should easily have 220+ carries this year.

What has me wondering is the heavy contract just given to Lewis. They're going to want yards for those dollars, and I'm just curious why they would pay that much when you could find a similar player on day 2 or even 3 if you're lucky. I like Henry as a runner at 1.02. But with Murray and now Lewis taking away from his production, I'm trying to shake the feeling I'm looking at another Jonathan Stewart.

FWIW my vote is Henry

NON PPR, Henry is way more valuable. He's going to get early down work and goal line work. That's what you want in NON PPR. Way less RB's are relevant in NON PPR. I would not pay the 1.02, however. 1.05 seems fair. No guarantee a RB you take at 1.05 is even getting legitimate carries right out of the gate.

[Blackout]

Henry still in an "early 1st value" conversation ?! Ouch. Murray, Lewis...who's the next blocking him as a lead back ?

[jcc6fd]

Henry still in an "early 1st value" conversation ?! Ouch. Murray, Lewis...who's the next blocking him as a lead back ?

I want to say Henry is easily worth more than the 1.05 and in the 1.03-1.04 range, but I think we’re ignoring the magnitude of the Lewis signing. They gave him $20 million (11.5 guaranteed). That’s not satellite 3rd down back money. He’ll be getting lead back carries.

For that reason I can respect those favoring the 1.05 over him. People have been waiting so long for Henry to pay dividends and have had ample excuses for his lack of usage, but at what point is this Lamar Miller in Miami again where there were reasons for the lack of usage.