Rank the rookie QBS pre-combine/draft

[gmoftheyear]

Hi, Haven't had a lot of time to start studying the rookie signal callers coming out in April. Was wondering who people on the board really like before the combine and draft ramps up? You can rank em if you like or just make comments on what you've seen from the top prospects. The more the merrier. Thanks.

[gmoftheyear]

Yikes, I guess no one has studied the Rookie QB's yet?

[Bot101]

Mayfield
Rosen

Jackson

Darnold



Allen
Rudolph

[Nanananananana]

Darnold (never been this sold on a QB)



Allen
Mayfield
Rosen

Jackson

[AlPal&Ange]

Rosen

Mayfield
Darnold



Allen


Jackson




Rudolph


I'm a huge Rosen guy... may never be a Brady/Wentz/Wilson type of QB but definitely projects to a Matty Ice/ Eli Manning type for me.

[Bot101]

Darnold (never been this sold on a QB)



Allen
Mayfield
Rosen

Jackson

Was it his epic turnover rate vs good defenses or his early Justin Bieber hair style that convinced you?

[Cherokee]

Mayfield
Jackson
Allen

Darnold

Rosen

[clarion contrarion]

jackson - electric tools - if he gets it & is used properly , this will be so not close in 5 years

the rest of these guys are jags in my opinion

darnold - high end comp strong armed matt ryan reminds me of drew bledsoe a bit albeit more mobile version.
rosen - eli manning at best case


allen - matt stafford perhaps but doubtful if this were 20 years I would have him 1:1 like him 2nd best but accuracy dings him a couple spots - really think big ben is his best comp!


mayfield - 10% drew brees 90 % tim rattay - quick rattle off all the great big 12 qbs last 20 years !
white - like the moxy his interview with senior bowl nfl network guys he seems like a CEO type- it will take a while to get a shot





rudolph - way over rated john skelton 2.0

[DynoScout]

They all look like coin flips to me, and I'd rank them like this for dynasty fantasy football. The top 4 are all close enough that landing spot (who goes to which offensive coach/philosophy) will reset my final rankings. Look at Goff's first two years as an example - not good with Fisher, but much better with McVay.
Rosen
Jackson
Mayfield
Darnold
Allen

[Nanananananana]

Darnold (never been this sold on a QB)



Allen
Mayfield
Rosen

Jackson

Was it his epic turnover rate vs good defenses or his early Justin Bieber hair style that convinced you?

Mayfield’s look is way more boyband then Darnold, that headband is so douchey

[bsp27]

Mayfield
Jackson
Rosen

Darnold
Rudolph
Allen

[Bot101]

Darnold (never been this sold on a QB)



Allen
Mayfield
Rosen

Jackson

Was it his epic turnover rate vs good defenses or his early Justin Bieber hair style that convinced you?

Mayfield’s look is way more boyband then Darnold, that headband is so douchey

Oh for sure. Douchbag 101.

[hockeyBjj]

Man, rankings all sorts of different in hear

Write each of these ~6 Qbs names on a side of a dice and roll it apparently

[kris_kapsner]

From a fantasy perspective, the most valuable QB in this class over the next 4 years or so will be Jackson.

Mayfield will be a solid QB in my opinion and has a good chance of developing fairly quickly.

The rest need some development, not that the two above don't. So, the others I am more comfortable ranking after I see what coaching staff they land with. In fact, I'd be more likely to draft the guy who falls behind an aging vet than the guy who will start right away...at least if I'm looking long term.

[kadun2]

Darnold
Rosen
Jackson
Allen
Mayfield