For Fun - Worst Trade offers of 2018

[Mephistopheles]

I know there are those that will say this isn't that bad, but I think it is.

Give: Zeke
Get: Corey Davis, Chris Carson.

very bad.

It's much worse...
He offered the same package for any of my top 3 (Zeke, Hunt, DJ).
My response was that he has to start with Kamara in the deal to get any one of those 3 and he told me to bleep off.
Needless to say, won't be dealing with him again.

[DinoDynasty]

Give: Golladay
Receive: Ben Watson

Give: Godwin
Receive: Ben Watson

Give: Mike Williams
Get: Ben Watson

Give: Quincy
Receive: .’bet you can’t guess who... Ben Watson

I own Ertz and OJ Howard, we start 1 TE.

[bjd5211]

Give: Golladay
Receive: Ben Watson

Give: Godwin
Receive: Ben Watson

Give: Mike Williams
Get: Ben Watson

Give: Quincy
Receive: .’bet you can’t guess who... Ben Watson

I own Ertz and OJ Howard, we start 1 TE.

The not accounting for the other guys needs always bothers me more than bad valuations in trade offers.

[Pullo Vision]

Is there a rule that their points no longer count when they are "about to retire." Brady has been balling out and hasn't showed any signs of slowing down. Same with Olsen. Garcon is the 1 or 2 in San Fran, which everyone believes is on the rise.
You discount all these players, but say nothing about the fact that the only player on the other side that has played in the NFL put up a 34 525 1 season. Not horrible for a rookie, but unknown production for every player on that side.

I forgot to add.You are exaggerating greatly. Don't be dumb.

I'm fine with everything but the Olsen part. He certainly has shown signs of slowing down. He's injured again, may return this year and was reportedly considering retirement after that year's injury-plagued struggles.

[Pullo Vision]

Give Gronk
Get Dan Bailey

Where do I pick up my trophy?

This is awesome. Can't figure out what was the plan here. Message included? An attempt to express interest in Gronk? Maybe they thought you had a weakness at Kicker? lol

[grooner]

Give: Golladay
Receive: Ben Watson

Give: Godwin
Receive: Ben Watson

Give: Mike Williams
Get: Ben Watson

Give: Quincy
Receive: .’bet you can’t guess who... Ben Watson

I own Ertz and OJ Howard, we start 1 TE.

The not accounting for the other guys needs always bothers me more than bad valuations in trade offers.

Honestly I don't mind bad offers because sometimes it is because of different player evaluations and we can do some back and forth and reach an agreement.

I agree, It's the not accounting for needs that I hate. Like if I'm strong at te, I don't want to trade a player for another te that I don't need and can't use. Or if I'm rebuidling and they are offering me guys 30+ for a rookie, when clearly I don't want older guys as I have no shot of rebuidling. Those are the types of offers I just decline, as they make no sense for my team m

[smbkrypt24]

Is there a rule that their points no longer count when they are "about to retire." Brady has been balling out and hasn't showed any signs of slowing down. Same with Olsen. Garcon is the 1 or 2 in San Fran, which everyone believes is on the rise.
You discount all these players, but say nothing about the fact that the only player on the other side that has played in the NFL put up a 34 525 1 season. Not horrible for a rookie, but unknown production for every player on that side.

I forgot to add.You are exaggerating greatly. Don't be dumb.

I'm fine with everything but the Olsen part. He certainly has shown signs of slowing down. He's injured again, may return this year and was reportedly considering retirement after that year's injury-plagued struggles.

I certainly agree now that Olsen's value has taken a major hit. I wrote that before his injury.

[jcc6fd]

Give Gronk
Get Dan Bailey

Where do I pick up my trophy?

This is awesome. Can't figure out what was the plan here. Message included? An attempt to express interest in Gronk? Maybe they thought you had a weakness at Kicker? lol

I too think this crosses a line we had not yet here. Any additional details would be appreciated and surely humorous.

[saw061600]

Give Gronk
Get Dan Bailey

Where do I pick up my trophy?

This is awesome. Can't figure out what was the plan here. Message included? An attempt to express interest in Gronk? Maybe they thought you had a weakness at Kicker? lol

I too think this crosses a line we had not yet here. Any additional details would be appreciated and surely humorous.

Okay, so after I sent an email response explaining how TEs and Ks have vastly different values as well as explaining the within position depreciation of points (150+Gronk to 80 points TE 10 and such), I got this in return.

"I was looking at it from the prospective that each player is towards the end of there careers however with the kickers I seen so far Bailey may have to play another ten years and Gronk is done after this year to peruse an acting career. Your point explanation was very well written but you need to get the maximum points you can out of each category."

One other point of note here: I have Zuerline...you know, the K with the most points last year.

[Mephistopheles]

This is awesome. Can't figure out what was the plan here. Message included? An attempt to express interest in Gronk? Maybe they thought you had a weakness at Kicker? lol

I too think this crosses a line we had not yet here. Any additional details would be appreciated and surely humorous.

Okay, so after I sent an email response explaining how TEs and Ks have vastly different values as well as explaining the within position depreciation of points (150+Gronk to 80 points TE 10 and such), I got this in return.

"I was looking at it from the prospective that each player is towards the end of there careers however with the kickers I seen so far Bailey may have to play another ten years and Gronk is done after this year to peruse an acting career. Your point explanation was very well written but you need to get the maximum points you can out of each category."

One other point of note here: I have Zuerline...you know, the K with the most points last year.

And who is out with a groin injury indefinitely.

Sorry, couldn't resist.

[jizz in my pants]

Give: Golladay
Receive: Ben Watson

Give: Godwin
Receive: Ben Watson

Give: Mike Williams
Get: Ben Watson

Give: Quincy
Receive: .’bet you can’t guess who... Ben Watson

I own Ertz and OJ Howard, we start 1 TE.

[Pullo Vision]

Give: Golladay
Receive: Ben Watson

Give: Godwin
Receive: Ben Watson

Give: Mike Williams
Get: Ben Watson

Give: Quincy
Receive: .’bet you can’t guess who... Ben Watson

I own Ertz and OJ Howard, we start 1 TE.

This suggests he puts Enunwa on the same level as those WRs. Maybe you could pursue a Quincy trade with this owner and get something better in return... or maybe he just hates the other WRs...

[Pullo Vision]

Is there a rule that their points no longer count when they are "about to retire." Brady has been balling out and hasn't showed any signs of slowing down. Same with Olsen. Garcon is the 1 or 2 in San Fran, which everyone believes is on the rise.
You discount all these players, but say nothing about the fact that the only player on the other side that has played in the NFL put up a 34 525 1 season. Not horrible for a rookie, but unknown production for every player on that side.

I forgot to add.You are exaggerating greatly. Don't be dumb.

I'm fine with everything but the Olsen part. He certainly has shown signs of slowing down. He's injured again, may return this year and was reportedly considering retirement after that year's injury-plagued struggles.

I certainly agree now that Olsen's value has taken a major hit. I wrote that before his injury.

True, but even before his injury this year, the injury last year, extended recovery and talk he could go into broadcasting had already smashed his value.

I just had a problem with saying neither Brady nor Olsen had shown signs of slowing. Probably more a quibble with phrasing than actual production or value.

[DrNoish]

This is awesome. Can't figure out what was the plan here. Message included? An attempt to express interest in Gronk? Maybe they thought you had a weakness at Kicker? lol

I too think this crosses a line we had not yet here. Any additional details would be appreciated and surely humorous.

Okay, so after I sent an email response explaining how TEs and Ks have vastly different values as well as explaining the within position depreciation of points (150+Gronk to 80 points TE 10 and such), I got this in return.

"I was looking at it from the prospective that each player is towards the end of there careers however with the kickers I seen so far Bailey may have to play another ten years and Gronk is done after this year to peruse an acting career. Your point explanation was very well written but you need to get the maximum points you can out of each category."

One other point of note here: I have Zuerline...you know, the K with the most points last year.

Offer Zuerline for one of his older guys.

[A-train]

Got this offer for team 2 in my sig:
Give: Mahomes
Get: Roethlisberger

Yea cause my completely young rebuild team needs a quarterback who is most likely going to retire soon for a young QB with huge upside.