I think the deal is fine. Alshon has to be a runaway for most overrated player around here. The guy just had the same season as Dez Bryant, but in a better situation that can't really improve and will likely regress, and is only one year younger. Yet somehow that means the bottom has dropped out of Dez's value while Alshon's has gone up.Pullo Vision wrote: ↑Sat Feb 24, 2018 9:44 amIf RBs are this valuable, seems you undersold Hyde.sammyz wrote: ↑Thu Feb 22, 2018 12:21 pmUnderstandable. Context is important. RBs are basically untouchable in my league and so typically are draft picks in the top 5. I managed to keep my first rounder and I think sold high with Alshon at least, and quite possibly with Hyde.
If Guice and Sutton (projected to be my 1.07) put up even equivalent numbers to Alshon and Hyde (and Alshon was a bench player for me) then I think I came out ahead by acquiring rookies rather than players on the wrong side of 27 years old.
Also worth pointing out that I've had the roster to make the playoffs most years and am a contender but can never punch one in. I felt I really need to swing for the fences to try to upgrade in order to win a ship.
He was a TD dependent WR3 (WR25 ppg) on a top 5 offense that will likely regress some and is getting close to 30 and for some reason everyone is rushing out to buy.