Which of these 3rd-tier RBs do you believe in?

[lukkynumber13]

Jeez recency bias is one helluva drug. It's Tevin Coleman and it isn't particularly close.

For sure there is certainly some recency bias going on, as Collins and Drake have had monster games on national TV this month, but what is so exceptional about Coleman? He's never looked like a stud when he's been a feature back, at least not in my opinion.

[ArrylT]

Jeez recency bias is one helluva drug. It's Tevin Coleman and it isn't particularly close.

For sure there is certainly some recency bias going on, as Collins and Drake have had monster games on national TV this month, but what is so exceptional about Coleman? He's never looked like a stud when he's been a feature back, at least not in my opinion.

congratulations lukky13 on this being your 6666 th post*. Your bad karma quota has been fulfilled and from here on out you're only going to have good things happen to your teams (so long as you publicly announce that Donte Moncrief is worth 1.03 or more to you).

* - Just seems like an odd coincidence that I noticed an owner whose handle ends in 13 had their 6666th post.

[lukkynumber13]

Jeez recency bias is one helluva drug. It's Tevin Coleman and it isn't particularly close.

For sure there is certainly some recency bias going on, as Collins and Drake have had monster games on national TV this month, but what is so exceptional about Coleman? He's never looked like a stud when he's been a feature back, at least not in my opinion.

congratulations lukky13 on this being your 6666 th post*. Your bad karma quota has been fulfilled and from here on out you're only going to have good things happen to your teams (so long as you publicly announce that Donte Moncrief is worth 1.03 or more to you).

* - Just seems like an odd coincidence that I noticed an owner whose handle ends in 13 had their 6666th post.

hahaha thanks!

[skip]

Jeez recency bias is one helluva drug. It's Tevin Coleman and it isn't particularly close.

For sure there is certainly some recency bias going on, as Collins and Drake have had monster games on national TV this month, but what is so exceptional about Coleman? He's never looked like a stud when he's been a feature back, at least not in my opinion.

congratulations lukky13 on this being your 6666 th post*. Your bad karma quota has been fulfilled and from here on out you're only going to have good things happen to your teams (so long as you publicly announce that Donte Moncrief is worth 1.03 or more to you).

* - Just seems like an odd coincidence that I noticed an owner whose handle ends in 13 had their 6666th post.

ArrylT, Since you were looking (or waiting) for them:

viewtopic.php?f=6&t=152388&p=1369070&hi ... f#p1369070
In this comment, lukky says that Moncrief has "potential" but leaves him out being able to "sustain long term value".

viewtopic.php?f=6&t=150909&p=1357244&hi ... f#p1357244
States that the 2nd round pick in the trade may be more valuable than Moncrief.

[jcc6fd]

The list is not one that I would have thought to put together, though the thoughts and insight are very interesting.

Would have thought players with proven production and pedigree like Coleman and Crow would have been run-away winners but Crow is getting no love, despite his quiet resurgence in the second half of the season, and Coleman trails both Drake and Collins who appear to only have an edge in current (2017) opportunity.

Crow is a FA this offseason and I believe he'll be signed to be a team's, even if it's the Browns, lead back. I get that the Freeman timeshare is undesirable for Coleman but he's been consistently good with his opportunities. Seems like the poll results are reflective of a redraft mindset.

[Dirty Mike&the Boys]

Mack and Perine. Mack could be special, if management over there in Indy could get their heads out of their bleep*s

[Bot101]

Mack and Perine. Mack could be special, if management over there in Indy could get their heads out of their bleep*s

I dont see Mack ever being a 3 down type back. He seems like the type that produces more with limited touches.

[Pac_Eddy]

No love for Jamaal Williams. Been killing it for a month in Green Bay. Huh.

[lukkynumber13]

No love for Jamaal Williams. Been killing it for a month in Green Bay. Huh.

I found that very interesting as well! He wasn't one of my picks here, but I could make the argument that he has the highest ceiling out of all these dudes next year. IF he keeps the job and plays all 3 downs, he will be Aaron Rodgers' caddy. That's almost a lock for RB1 numbers.

[bsp27]

Jeez recency bias is one helluva drug. It's Tevin Coleman and it isn't particularly close.

For sure there is certainly some recency bias going on, as Collins and Drake have had monster games on national TV this month, but what is so exceptional about Coleman? He's never looked like a stud when he's been a feature back, at least not in my opinion.

He is much more athletic than any other running back here, has the longest and most thorough sample size of efficiency and production at the NFL level, and was the most productive in college.

[Pet_Smith]

For me it was Coleman waaaaaay ahead of the rest.
I voted Foreman too, but that's conditional on the Achilles recovery. Crow was the only other I'd have considered voting for.

Collins / Drake etc are prime sell high / get what you can for them in my opinion - but then I had Collins on taxi all last year up to the point he got cut by the 'Hawks, and then dropped him, so what do I know!!!

[joshb]

No love for Jamaal Williams. Been killing it for a month in Green Bay. Huh.

I found that very interesting as well! He wasn't one of my picks here, but I could make the argument that he has the highest ceiling out of all these dudes next year. IF he keeps the job and plays all 3 downs, he will be Aaron Rodgers' caddy. That's almost a lock for RB1 numbers.

I really have a hard time seeing him escaping a RBBC. In my opinion Jones is still the better pure runner, and if he is able to improve his pass blocking he'll siphon enough touches from Williams to make both of them less valuable.

[nathanq42]

For me its Collins and Coleman, both look good, Collins has a clearer path to lead dog status, but I think Coleman is a superior talent with a tougher path to touches

[lukkynumber13]

If Derrick Henry was included here, would you rank him above every other RB?

[Pet_Smith]

I'd have him tied with Coleman - but probably a touch ahead