Best prospect

[Tennisbuck]

Bear young WR prospect

[dynastyninja]

Williams>Doctson>>>>>>Treadwell

[jcc6fd]

Williams gets the benefit of the doubt simply because he's had the least amount of time to prove himself.

After Williams it's Doctson over Treadwell and I don't see much of an argument for this being inversed.

[lukkynumber13]

Treadwell has 2 more votes than Doctson????

[Franky Four Fingers]

Give me Doctson, all three are talented as evidenced by their 1st round pedigrees. The tiebreaker for me is situation. Doctson has a much easier and clearer path to being his NFL teams wr1. Minnesota has Diggs and Thelon. San Diego has a 25 year old Keenan Allen. If I'm not mistaken all of Pryor, Crowder, and Grant have expiring contracts. Health will definitely play a role but Doctson has already begun to flash this year when on the field and could be priming for a traditional 3rd year breakout. People don't seem to have the patience to wait for this jump anymore.

[Servo]

We're about halfway through the season now:

- Doctson completely worthless, even with Pryor and Crowder being zeros....has not done anything. Incredible on all fronts for Washington. People calling them a superbowl contender with Chris Thompson as their best player? Come on now.

- At least Treadwell has caught a ball or two, but as long as Diggs and Theilen remain healthy....Treadwell isn't surpassing them IMO

- Williams, crowded....very crowded. IMHO, that offense should run through Melvin Gordon and Hunter Henry. Sprinkle Keenan Allen and Benjamin in there and BOOM, the Chargers have won 3 straight games following that MO.

Ugly all around, I don't like the choice but I'd probably say Doctson because 1...dear GOD...1 Washington WR has to step up.

[DinoDynasty]

M Williams>Doctson>>>Treadwell.

I remember Dabo said that Williams was the most complete receiver he has ever coached. His comments on Watson appear to be true to his word, so I'll put some stock in that.

[jcc6fd]

We're about halfway through the season now:

- Doctson completely worthless, even with Pryor and Crowder being zeros....has not done anything. Incredible on all fronts for Washington. People calling them a superbowl contender with Chris Thompson as their best player? Come on now.

- At least Treadwell has caught a ball or two, but as long as Diggs and Theilen remain healthy....Treadwell isn't surpassing them IMO

- Williams, crowded....very crowded. IMHO, that offense should run through Melvin Gordon and Hunter Henry. Sprinkle Keenan Allen and Benjamin in there and BOOM, the Chargers have won 3 straight games following that MO.

Ugly all around, I don't like the choice but I'd probably say Doctson because 1...dear GOD...1 Washington WR has to step up.

At first I thought this post was from a month ago. Doctson has shown promise. If you're saying he's worthless because he hasn't won anyone a fantasy matchup then I guess I can see that, but from a dynasty standpoint he's shown more than either of the other two. In fact he overtook the number 1 WR role last week. Today's outlook for Doctson is far better than the worst case scenario that could have been envisioned before the seasons started.

Not even going to comment on how you seem to give Treadwell a more favorable review here.

[maxhyde]

For me it is Mike Williams

[Concept Coop]

For me it is Mike Williams

This is the only right answer. He has a much higher draft pedigree and is much earlier in the process. I wouldn't trade Williams for Doctson and Treadwell.

[seahawks506]

I voted Treadwell because I felt bad for the 4 lonely supporters

[Valhalla]

I voted Treadwell because I felt bad for the 4 lonely supporters

[CIA]

Doctson and I don’t think it’s close. He’s better in the air than Williams and Treadwell. He’s faster than both and he also runs better routes than both. Doctson’s issues are purely injury related. He has shown flashes already and he will continue to grow. He’s more athletic and he’s also the better football player. As long as cousins stays in town, Doctson will be fine barring injury. He has the better qb long term at this point as Rivers is nearing the end and bridgewater has shown nothing to suggest he will be a great qb.

[meineymoe]

I feel like I have an emotional attachment to this topic because these three were my WR corps in my college league a couple of seasons ago

I really enjoyed Doctson and his production, and of course Treadwell was my stud, while Williams was the young upcomer with the Clemson pedigree. I wasn't really that excited about Doctson at the next level, but expected much more from Treadwell, which is why I focused on him in last season's rookie drafts. So, I won't be giving up on Treadwell, just yet.

I'm still not that high on Doctson, but I am curious to see how he handles his opportunity now in Washington. I hope he does have success, though I'm still not buying at his price right now.

If I was going to try to pry someone away from another owner, it would be Williams. I fact, I should probably do it today, because you just never know when that big breakout game could come - maybe as soon as this week, though I'm suspecting after the bye.

Anyway - my vote is Williams... at this time. I probably like Treadwell more than the average, but I think it's time to see what Mike can do!

-oo-

[BigBawseRoss]

dont know enough about mike williams but i am liking the way docston is trending...although he needs way more targets to go along with the snaps. i hate the redskins O this year...its really bad and idk why