Rank your top 12 Dynasty QBs

[TheChicken]

The issue with lists like this is it omits likely ADP (if a start up) or trade cost (if a mature league). Unless it is s/flex or 2QB I'm not owning Luck or Rodgers, yet they would be my top two.

My 'value/targeted' Top 12
1 Brees
2 Brady
3 Cam
4 Ryan
5 Winston
6 Rivers
7 Tyrod
8 Wilson
9 Rodgers
10 Dalton
11 Luck
12 Mariota

[Space Cowboy]

dak is way too low in most of these lists.

[Tsunami]

1. Rodgers
2. Wilson
3. Ryan
4. Cousins
5. Luck
6. Carr
7. Taylor
8. Mariota
9. Newton
10.Winston
11.Prescott
12.Wentz

[Cowboysfan33]

dak is way too low in most of these lists.

I agree and not just because I'm a Cowboys fan. Our defense over-achieved, partly because of our running game, time of possession, etc. Now we lose Barry Church, who is under-rated, Brandon Carr, Mo Claiborne, JJ Wilcox,Terrell McClain, Jack Crawford and even though some of those guys aren't household names, they are key parts of the d-line rotation and depth for the secondary. Dak will be throwing alot more next season and you know he will get at least a handful of rushing TDs, even if he doesn't match his total from last season, I think he will easily surpass his passing TDs, mainly do to probable shootouts.

[Valhalla]

Rodgers
Luck
-------
Wilson
Ryan
Carr
Mariota
Dak
Cam
Brady
Winston
Brees
Stafford

*to the "where's Bradford!!!" comment, I've probably offered the most support for him recently, but that's in defense of him not being the #32 dynasty QB. There's a big window between 32 and 12...and personally I have him closer to 12 than 32

To continue to Bradford...I'd put Cousins, Rivers, Wentz, Roethlisberger, Dalton, and maybe Tannehill above Bradford. So I suppose he's ~#19 for me. I want nothing to do with the future of Bortles. Palmer has been good but I believe is soon to be done and I don't think his final years will pay off like a Brady or Brees. I don't think Eli will be much better than Bradford, if at all, and Eli is possibly on his last effective legs. Taylor, Flacco and Smith...well they just don't offer the same per-game upside. When it comes to guys this low, I'll bet on the higher upside (which I believe is betting on Bradford playing a full season behind a semi-adequate line). Putting him at 19 may be high for some of you, but I was simply arguing that putting him at 32 was pretty off-base.

[Bison]

Luck
Rodgers
Carr
Newton
Wilson
Wentz
Winston
Mariota
Prescott
Ryan
Stafford
Brady

[DonJulio]

1. Tyrod Taylor
2. Tyrod Taylor
3. Tyrod Taylor
4. Tyrod Taylor
5. Tyrod Taylor
6. Tyrod Taylor
7. Tyrod Taylor
8. Tyrod Taylor
9. Tyrod Taylor
10. Tyrod Taylor
11. Tyrod Taylor
12. Tyrod Taylor

[Westy22]

1. Luck
2. Rodgers
3. Carr
4. Mariota
5. Wilson
6. Winston
7. Newton
8. Wentz
9. Prescott
10. Ryan
11. Stafford
12. Cousins

[koalabear]

Surprised by the Wentz love, is he that good? He's my only QB in a rebuild so glad to see he is valued, on potential I assume.

I thought he had some mechanical issues last season, hopefully that can be ironed out and he can be a solid top 12 option.

[Pac_Eddy]

Tier 1: Luck, Rodgers

Tier 2: Wilson, Carr, Newton, Brady

Tier 3: Prescott, Ryan, Mariota, Winston

Tier 4: Stafford, Brees

[IBall2]

1. Tyrod Taylor
2. Tyrod Taylor
3. Tyrod Taylor
4. Tyrod Taylor
5. Tyrod Taylor
6. Tyrod Taylor
7. Tyrod Taylor
8. Tyrod Taylor
9. Tyrod Taylor
10. Tyrod Taylor
11. Tyrod Taylor
12. Tyrod Taylor

I'd probably swap #4 and #7 but besides that, looks good.

[cornhole2412]

Luck
Rodgers
Russell
Cam
Winston
Mariota
Carr
Stafford
Ryan
Brady
Dak
Wentz (Age has everything to do with this pick)

[Bison]

Surprised by the Wentz love, is he that good? He's my only QB in a rebuild so glad to see he is valued, on potential I assume.

I thought he had some mechanical issues last season, hopefully that can be ironed out and he can be a solid top 12 option.

FWIW, I'm a Wentz (NDSU) fan, so you can take my rankings with a grain of salt if you want. However, I've watched him a lot and I can't see a reason he doesn't float up to the elite QB level. It will be a year or two yet, but in dynasty if you can get an elite QB for much of his whole career that is pretty valuable.

I'd bet my left nut he will have a better fantasy career than Dak, and I like Dak a lot too.

[clarion contrarion]

he had best stop playing like he is trying out to be a crash test dummy or he won't last long . I was very impressed otherthan that part however.

wonder if keenum can beat out bradford in minny ?

[lukkynumber13]

Rodgers
Luck
---
Wilson
M. Ryan
Carr
Mariota
Jameis
Cousins
Cam
---
Dak
Brady
Brees


Stafford, Big Ben, Rivers, Wentz, Tyrod probably make up the next tier for me.