1.03

[sdonegon]

12 team Sf in sig. 5 points passing td and ppr

Mu guess is Barkley and Mayfield will be taken in the first 2 picks.

Do i take Rosen or Jackson or Guice or Darnold?

[alphaxray]

Im certainly taking a QB based on your current roster. As for which one, thats up to you and your philosophy. If you want to swing for a home run, go Lamar. If you are more comfortable with a solid double, go Rosen.

[joeya2001]

Agree with the above, your QBs may have 2-3 years left you need to address the need at QB

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Eh...yeah you need youth at QB, but you're set up to compete now. I see Mayfield in his own tier at QB, so I'd take Guice if he's gone at 1.02. My feeling is a lot who are down on Guice right now will be regretting not taking him once he does well in a loaded WAS offense with a decent line. I'd take Guice, and that gives you RB depth to trade Guice later or trade one of your other RBs for a young QB. Your other option would be to see if the 1.02 owner is willing to sell for 1.03 + Tannehill + 2019 2nd or something along those lines.

[sdonegon]

My struggle is Rosen or Guice. Assuming Mayfield is gone. I like Guice a lot and dont need a qb this year. Have 3 starters but this league values qbs pretty high so getting a young qb will be an arm and a leg. Defending Champ too if that matters any. lol

[Servo]

Clearly, no league is the same, but there's my gut feeling that QBs should go earlier than in year's past...might be due in part that 5 were taken in the first round versus the normal 2 or 3.

Maybe on the contrary, you could have people think...oh...well at least 1 should fall to me and I'll keep taking skill players until that happens.

I'm in a similar predicament and have no idea of what to do.

[sdonegon]

my league over values qbs even for a 5pt td SF so that's my only concern if I went Guice. Its a really active league but I could have to give up too many future assets to get a younger Qb once brady dies.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

my league over values qbs even for a 5pt td SF so that's my only concern if I went Guice. Its a really active league but I could have to give up too many future assets to get a younger Qb once brady dies.

1. They should value QBs highly in a superflex format that awards 5pt passing TDs.
2. In that case, go with your no. 2 rookie QB assuming Mayfield is gone.

[moishetreats]

1.01 = Barkley
1.02 = Mayfield/Guice
1.03 = Guice/Mayfield

Yes, you need a QB. But, is there any QB that you are really confident in aside from Mayfield?? None for me. None. If you do have a QB whom you love, then you can take him at 1.03. But, no way that I'd pass on Guice for a QB just to get a QB.

[keebs3]

I was in a similar boat with the 1.04. my rankings going into the pick was: Mayfield, Guice, Rosen.

I got lucky when Darnold and Penny went 2/3 but I still had a hard time going Mayfield over Guice- but I also have a solid QB core already. For your team I'd probably go Rosen then Guice.

[SnidelyWhiplash]

Mayfield
Guice
Rosen

[sdonegon]

Ended up going Rosen. Guice fell to 6. Tried to trade back up to 6 but the price was too steep. The trade I lost out to was Jordan Howard and Dalton for 1.06 and Bortles.

[mmass]

Ended up going Rosen. Guice fell to 6. Tried to trade back up to 6 but the price was too steep. The trade I lost out to was Jordan Howard and Dalton for 1.06 and Bortles.

Guy gave up way to much in that deal... hard to beat that bargin

[sdonegon]

yeah seemed like a lot.

[Pete Carroll's Gum]

I'm at the 1.03 as well and my draft is on Sunday. I'm assuming a QB will go at 1.02, I assume it will be Mayfield. If it is, I'm heavily contemplating taking Jackson. I don't need him to start this year, as I have 3 starting QBs.

I didn't see any love for Lamar in the posts above. Thoughts?