Carr or Winston?

[playa_hata]

Just wondering who has more value to the dynasty community its a 5pt td -2Int league 12 teams ppr scoring.

[gunzwil guinea pigs]

I think its close, same tier for me, but I like Carr and his supporting cast a bit more

[playa_hata]

I think its close, same tier for me, but I like Carr and his supporting cast a bit more

Really? I think Evans,Godwin, Brate, Howard, RoJo is far superior to Carrs supporting cast Carr has no rb help and Amari cooper i think jordy and martavis are nothing special. but i do think carr is the better player.

[gunzwil guinea pigs]

I think its close, same tier for me, but I like Carr and his supporting cast a bit more

Really? I think Evans,Godwin, Brate, Howard, RoJo is far superior to Carrs supporting cast Carr has no rb help and Amari cooper i think jordy and martavis are nothing special. but i do think carr is the better player.

I disagree, O-Line in okland is at least 2 tiers above the one in tampa. Evans is the best skill player I agrre, but Cooper is fine, marty a field strechter like godwin but much more athletic, brate is JAG, Jordy is old but a nice red zone target. The RB comittee in Okland is such as good as RoJo and Barber.

[Smoking Guns]

I think Carr is better QB - Winston has better support . Good thing is they are both likely to be playing from behind a lot , especially Winston with the division they are in.

[moishetreats]

Right now, I think that Carr is the better QB.

I think that Winston has the higher ceiling, though -- and by a lot. In addition, I don't think that Winston's floor is that much lower than Carr's. So, I'd take Winston -- pretty easily.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

I'd say it's close. Winston = Carr + 2nd

[Phaded]

I would rather have Winston pretty easily, I think he has top 5 potential.

Derek Carr is a higher paid Andy Dalton.
(I like Dalton and think both are fine QBs but lack a high ceiling)

[blacklab1010]

This is interesting because i have both of these qbs. I would just like to add that in our 4pt pass league winston missed essentially 4 games and still sxored almost exact same pts as carr!

[joeya2001]

I like Winstons Cast better
I like Carr as a QB better

[Servo]

Wonder if Jameis falls on the hot seat this year if he throws up another disappointing season?

[Phaded]

...how has Winston been disappointing?
Just curious to the logic.

[ImaRounder]

I took them at 3.12 and 4.01 startup last week. So i think theyre equal.

[FantasyFreak]

I would rather have Winston pretty easily, I think he has top 5 potential.

Derek Carr is a higher paid Andy Dalton.
(I like Dalton and think both are fine QBs but lack a high ceiling)

Carr had an MVP caliber season 2 years ago before getting hurt, so I think Andy Dalton is a pretty poor comparison.

[Blueboy]

I would rather have Winston pretty easily, I think he has top 5 potential.

Derek Carr is a higher paid Andy Dalton.
(I like Dalton and think both are fine QBs but lack a high ceiling)

Carr had an MVP caliber season 2 years ago before getting hurt, so I think Andy Dalton is a pretty poor comparison.

Dalton has had an MVP caliber season