So it turns out I actually CAN score sack yardage independently.
I just don't know how that would work in conjunction with passing yards, since sacks count against passing yards too. I don't want to "double-dip" on the penalty for sack yardage...
2017 Rule Change Proposal - QB Scoring
Moderator: TrueDawg
Re: 2017 Rule Change Proposal - QB Scoring
Interesting...
Well, if passing yards stay consistent at 1/20, then you simply make sack yards -1/20 and let it be double dipped. 1/20 * 2 = 1/10, same as rushing. That said, I think the passing yards are a much bigger issue. If passing yards switch to 1/25, then...
A 10 yard sack would be -0.4, so we'd need the "sack penalty" on that to be -0.6, to make a sack = a negative rushing play (for a RB/WR). If my quick math was correct, then a sack would need to be scored at -1/16.666667 yards.
Re: 2017 Rule Change Proposal - QB Scoring
Right...that was my thought as well. Just make it so the two add up to -1 point per 10 yards.Xulu Bak wrote: ↑Tue Jun 06, 2017 12:09 pm Interesting...
Well, if passing yards stay consistent at 1/20, then you simply make sack yards -1/20 and let it be double dipped. 1/20 * 2 = 1/10, same as rushing. That said, I think the passing yards are a much bigger issue. If passing yards switch to 1/25, then...
A 10 yard sack would be -0.4, so we'd need the "sack penalty" on that to be -0.6, to make a sack = a negative rushing play (for a RB/WR). If my quick math was correct, then a sack would need to be scored at -1/16.666667 yards.
-
- Captain
- Posts: 770
- Joined: Wed Aug 05, 2015 7:46 am
- Location: Michigan
Re: 2017 Rule Change Proposal - QB Scoring
I would keep this as is.
-
- All Pro
- Posts: 1921
- Joined: Sun Aug 02, 2015 7:18 pm
Re: 2017 Rule Change Proposal - QB Scoring
QB scoring is absolutely terrible in this league, but I'm done arguing it. I'll vote yes to change and punish if we get a vote. If not, I have Carr so whatever. Alex Smith is probably a better player than Julio Jones, right?
Re: 2017 Rule Change Proposal - QB Scoring
I'd vote to leave as is
Re: 2017 Rule Change Proposal - QB Scoring
Keep it as it is... Some of us have sculpted our teams around the current QB scoring. A tweek is one thing but a total overhaul of the scoring of the highest scoring position is not a good idea, IMO.
Re: 2017 Rule Change Proposal - QB Scoring
There's going to be a lot of arguing over this...and only like half the league has even commented. So in the interests of my sanity (and to keep things moving), I'm tabling it.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 22 guests